Select Genre

   Essentials

   Highlights

   Search Options


Get Download Manager Now
Feedback
COL Gift Certificates
Newsletter Archive
Find Us in Facebook
Follow Us on Twitter
NaxosRip.com
 

  Critics' Picks

This week's great reviews from the leading specialized magazines, quality dailies and online review sites.
 (21 January – 3 February)




D'Anglebert: Suites Nos. 1 - 4
(Naxos: 8.570472-73)

D'Anglebert: Suites Nos. 1 - 4 Those who like the keyboard creations of Jean-Philippe Rameau (1683-1764) and Francois Couperin (1668-1733) are going to fall in love with these lovely pieces by Jean-Henry D'Anglebert (1629-1691). A close associate of the great Jean-Baptiste Lully (1632-1687), he was Louis XIV's harpsichordist, and wrote only for the keyboard. His compositions, while not actual transcriptions of lute music, were greatly influenced by it. Consequently there's a vertical harmonic simplicity and dynamic uniformity about the four suites here that make them some of the most melodic harpsichord music to come out of the French baroque. Not only that, but D'Anglebert was a master of ornamentation, which adds an amazing degree of variety and color to these scores.

All of these factors are further enhanced by performances featuring a soloist who is a consummate "ornamentalist," playing two extraordinary instruments. Both built by Keith Hill, one is modeled after a two-manual harpsichord from the renowned mid-eighteenth century Parisian builder Francois Blanchet. The other is a real rarity because it's a recreation of a lute-harpsichord, none of which have survived to the present day. With gut rather than metal strings, Hill made it as per documentation dating from 1768 describing one built for Johann Sebastian Bach.

Published in 1689, D'Anglebert's Pièces de Clavecin included the suites presented here, plus nineteen transcriptions from Lully operas (see the newsletter of 11 July 2007) and other unnamed sources. The first and fourth suites are in major keys and played on the lute-harpsichord. Highlights from the first include an allemande, which is a superb example of the brisé, or broken arpeggiated style of keyboard writing inspired by lute music. Then there's a chaconne rondeau that's quite regal in bearing, and a plucky concluding menuet, which sparkles with iridescent ornamentation.

The fourth suite is the shortest with a joie de vivre that sets it apart from the rest. It includes a catchy gigue and a festive chaconne rondeau where campanella effects mimic the tolling of bells. The concluding Tombeau de Chambonnières is a moving tribute to the composer's teacher, the great French harpsichordist Jacques Champion de Chambonnières (1601-1672).

The middle suites are played on the Blanchet-inspired instrument, and what a wonderful sounding harpsichord it is. Just listen to the beautifully rounded tone of the prelude and percussively infectious courantes in the second suite. The final passacaille is a showpiece for many of those ornaments that are a D'Angelbert trademark. Incidentally, those interested in them will find further details in the highly informative album notes, or the 1689 publication mentioned above, which includes particulars about their notation and execution.

The third suite is the longest, lasting about three-quarters of an hour. Here the composer regales us with a twelve-minute Folies d'Espagne which is a mesmerizing, ingenious set of twenty-two variations on the familiar fifteenth century Portuguese dance tune La Folia.

A specialist in keyboard works of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, Elizabeth Farr's performances leave what little competition there is in the dust. Besides sheer technical ability, she has that exceptional sense of rhythm and phrasing that is so vital to these keyboard works. In the hands of lesser artists, highly ornamented music like this can become stilted or even awkward sounding. But that's certainly not the case with Farr whose digital dexterity and unfailing sense of timing insure smooth traversals of all these suites.

Demonstration quality sound makes this delectable baroque offering all the more appealing. Spread over a relatively broad soundstage, both instruments come across with a clarity and lifelike detail that are exceptional. Audiophiles and harpsichord enthusiasts alike will be totally captivated by this album. And those liking the dulcet tones of the lute-harpsichord should investigate an earlier Naxos release (8570470-71) with Ms. Farr playing the lute music of J.S. Bach on it.

Classical Lost and Found, Bob McQuiston
http://www.clofo.com/Newsletters/C081218.htm



Debussy: Complete Works for Piano, Vol. 4
(Chandos: CHAN 10497)

Debussy: Complete Works for Piano, Vol. 4 Jean-Efflam of Debussy’s style and sound world yields ravishing, freshly minted interpretations of the Images and Etudes that proudly rank with (and sometimes surpass) the catalogue’s reference versions. The Images gain welcome nourishment from Bavouzet’s portfolio of ravishing colour shadings and articulations, while easily absorbing such liberties as playing  one hand before the other à la  Michelangeli. His headlong, impulsive “Homage à Rameau” contrasts with similarly nuanced yet more austere readings. In “Possins d’or”, he sneaks a few piranhas in to the fishbowl as he modifies Debussy’s aussi léger que possible directive with volatile dynamic hairpins and witty accents. “Er la lune descend sÛr le temple qui fut” also rivets your attention via his seductive legato and three-dimensional textures.

Although I’m not familiar with bavouzet’s earlier Etudes edition on Canyon Classics, his Chandos remake may well be the best I’ve heard. Mitsuko Uchida’s steely precision, Florent Boffard’s luscious tone, plus Ju-Ying Song’s poise and clarity all roll into one and beyond in Bavouzet’s respectful yet imaginative hands. As you follow the intelligently contoured left-hand counterlines of “Pour les tierces” you almost don’t notice the fluency and easy evenness of Bavouzet’s right hand, in “Pour les huit doigts” and “Pour les degrés chromatiques” he favours melodic inflection and linear motion over Aimard’s and Uchida’s smoother, scintillating surfaces. The difficult leaps of “Pour les accords” have rarely sounded less like technical feats and more like music, and “Pour les arpèges composés” rivals Horowitz’s 1965 reading for harmonic pointing and sexiness.

Bavouzet precedes this etude with a full-bodied, emotionally generous performace of its recently rediscovered earlier version, Etude retrouvée. I can guarantee readers that this attractively engineered release will reveal more and more details to savour with each rehearing. If you haven’t yet ordered it, what are you waiting for?

Gramophone, Jed Distler



Grieg: Peer Gynt (Complete Incidental Music)
(Naxos: 8.570871-72)

Grieg: Peer Gynt (Complete Incidental Music)

If you enjoyed Bjarte Engeset's excellent disc of the Peer Gynt Suites, then you'll certainly like this version of the complete incidental music as much if not more. Normally I prefer "extended excerpts" without the dialogue, but it's all so well done here that I find it impossible to complain. In fact, this set is every bit as fine as the competition on BIS, with excellent soloists (especially the Solveig of soprano Ise Katharina Gericke), an enthusiastic chorus, and extremely atmospheric engineering. All of the popular numbers from the suites (Morning, Anitra's Dance, Ase's Death, In the Hall of the Mountain King, etc.) are played to the hilt, and the extended scene with the trolls is really exciting under Engeset's leadership. Additionally, the couplings are unusual and very welcome.

Bergliot is a melodrama--that is, music accompanied by dialogue--and for that reason it never will be one of Grieg's more popular pieces. Still, it's very enjoyable, full of colorful effects, and the text (about a Viking woman's desire to avenge the death of her husband and son) is very dramatic. It's certainly worth getting to know, and it really does make the perfect companion to the complete Peer Gynt score, which after all has its share of speech against music as well. At Naxos' very reasonable price, this set becomes self-recommending. Texts and translations are available on the Naxos website.

Classics Today.com, David Hurwitz
http://classicstoday.com/review.asp?ReviewNum=12037



Rautavaara: Complete Works for Male Choir
(Ondine: ODE 1125-2D)

Rautavaara: Complete Works for Male Choir This second “complete” anthology of Rautavaara’s output for male choir to appear on CD. Amici Cantus conducted by Hannu Norjanen recorded a set in the mid-1990s (Finlandia - nla), but Rautavaara has since composed two further songs sets (more than 22 minutes of music). Otherwise only a handful of smaller items, such as the beautiful early Ave Maria (1957) and Legend (1985), are available (from Ondine, coincidentally), so this comprehensive and magnificently sung new collection has the field to itself.

For those familiar with Amici Cantus’s original set, this successor is very different. First, YL divide up the works between the main body and their 10-man offshoot, the Talla Vocal Ensemble – the latter, incidentally, are superb in the two TS Eliot Preludes (1956, rev 1967). Second, Ondine’s recording is richer, with more presence, matched by singing of greater urgency and vividness. Third, YL and Talla’s interpretations have more impetus and power, as in the half-hour-long A Book of Life (1972), which is split between poems – including texts by Rilke, Rimbaud, Goethe Emily Dickinson and Whitman – in five languages.

The Greater textural palette attained through using two differently sized choirs is more akin to that found in some early-music recordings. Perhaps there’s a loss of intimacy and a certain dreamy quality compared to Amici Cantus – for instance in the Psalms (1968-71) or some of the folksongs arrangements. But this is a small price to pay for the gains elsewhere, which for collectors of Rautavaara will chiefly be the quartets of songs to poems by Aleksis Kivi (arr 2005) or from the opera Rasputin (arr 2006), not otherwise issued.

Gramophone, Guy Rickards



Stravinsky: Requiem Canticles
(Haenssler Classic: CD93.226)

Stravinsky: Requiem Canticles There’s something I find very appealing about the austerity of late Stravinsky, three examples of which comprise this fine disc from Michael Gielen, a conductor we hear too little in the UK. Both Conticum Sacrum and Requiem Canticles have Venetian connections: the former was dedicated to the city and premiered in St. Mark’s, from whose architectural structure it derives its musical shape, while the latter, Stravinsky’s last major composition, was played at the composer’s funeral service in San Giovanni e Paolo. Gielen’s readings are as sharply etched as the music, and he is no less successful in the 20-minute ballet, Agon.

Philip Reed




Tchaikovsky: Hamlet
(PentaTone: PTC5186330)

Tchaikovsky: Hamlet

Phew! What a relief to learn that the Russian National Orchestra can, after all, play Russian music when working with a conductor who knows what he is doing. Not all of Vladimir Jurowski's recordings with this orchestra have been excellent (Prokofiev's Fifth was a big disappointment, for example), but this one certainly is. Having unusual, not over-recorded repertoire certainly helps. Tchaikovsky's incidential music to Hamlet consists of a reduced version of the symphonic poem we all know and (some of us) love, with a bunch of interludes, fanfares, melodramas, and songs filling out about 45 minutes of music. Not all of it is top-drawer Tchaikovsky, but it is colorful, tuneful, atmospheric, and utterly characteristic. It's also played to the hilt and magnificently recorded, with Tatiana Monogarova a nicely vulnerable Ophelia in her two songs (the bass gets a brief gravedigger's song, and that's it).

Tchaikovsky's original version of Romeo and Juliet is substantially shorter than the more familiar revised score (about seven minutes in this performance) largely on account of the totally different introduction and briefer coda. The battle music is the same, but the development section and final climax are completely different, and Friar Lawrence is missing (and I personally couldn't care less). I actually like the original introduction better than the later one, but from the start of the battle onward Tchaikovsky's second thoughts are uniformly superior. This is clearly the best recording of the 1869 original to date: it's taut and exciting, and Jurowski lets the cymbals, bass drum, and timpani go nuts at all the right places. Here, then, is a terrific disc to fill out your already more-or-less complete Tchaikovsky collection.

ClassicsToday.com, David Hurwitz
http://classicstoday.com/review.asp?ReviewNum=12009




Critics' Picks Archive


2010 2009 2008


Affiliates  |  Classical Points  |  Press Room  |  About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Terms of Use  |  Privacy Policy

Bach   •   Beethoven   •   Handel   •   Mozart   •   Tchaikovsky   •   Vivaldi

ClassicsOnline Newsletter Archive

Monthly Features on ClassicsOnline

ClassicsOnline is your number one source for the newest classical music releases, standards, rarities and bargains from the most popular independent labels, with the largest online classical music catalogue of over 1 Million tracks and more than 50,000 classical music albums available in CD, MP3 (320kbps) and FLAC (lossless format). Recently honored with the 2010 Best Classical Download Site by the MIDEM Classical Awards Jury, ClassicsOnline proves to have a devoted following of classical music enthusiasts and audiophiles worldwide.

ClassicsOnline offers an enormous range of specialist repertoire not available from other classical music online stores. More than 500 new classical music albums are added every month, all at competitive prices. Other notable offerings include: Free preview streaming of every album/track, special advanced search facility enables you to find your favorite classical music composers/artists/works/albums, and DRM-free tracks allows you to ‘burn’ tracks to an unlimited number of CDs or transfer them to an mp3 player or iPod for personal use. Membership is free, and registration includes 5 free tracks for download. Get more free tracks every week and gain access to exclusive classical deals when you subscribe to our newsletter. Enter your email on the left side-bar under newsletter subscription to start getting your weekly free track.
Some titles may not be available in all countries because of possible copyright or licensing restrictions.

Copyright © 2012 Naxos Digital Services Ltd. All rights reserved.
Classicsonline.com – Your Classical Music Download Source
1:27:09 AM May-29-12  -211-