Select Genre

   Essentials

   Highlights

   Search Options


Get Download Manager Now
Feedback
COL Gift Certificates
Newsletter Archive
Find Us in Facebook
Follow Us on Twitter
NaxosRip.com
 

  Critics' Picks

This week's great reviews from the leading specialized magazines, quality dailies and online review sites.
 (10 December – 23 December)




Tchaikovsky: Manfred Symphony; Voyevoda
(Naxos: 8.570568)

Tchaikovsky: Manfred Symphony; Voyevoda

Tchaikovsky's huge programme symphony after Byron's dramatic poem is no pushover for a conductor. Holding the sprawling structure together is just as important as projecting its dramatic highpoints with maximum intensity, and it's to the credit of Vassily Petrenko and the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic - which he has revitalised in his first two seasons as its principal conductor - that there isn't a single moment in this performance when one wishes for the cuts that were once routinely inflicted on the score. Petrenko makes every bar count, even in the slow movement, which depicts the Byronic hero's pastoral idyll and is arguably the weakest section of the whole work; the delicacy of the RLPO's playing here, and in the gossamer scherzo that precedes it, is exceptional. The recording does have an aggressive edge, which can make the climaxes - especially in the great finale - a bit of a trial. But at a bargain price, and with an equally supercharged account of the early symphonic ballad Voyevoda included as well, the disc is highly recommended.

The Guardian, Andrew Clements
http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/2008/oct/17/classicalmusicandopera-culturaltrips



Saint-Saens: Cello Concertos Nos. 1 & 2; Suite in D minor; Allegro appassionato; The Swan
(Haenssler Classic: CD93.222)

Saint-Saens: Cello Concertos Nos. 1 & 2;  Suite in D minor;  Allegro  appassionato;  The Swan

This delightful new release easily takes its place as the reference edition for these works, not that we're spoiled for choice in anything but the First cello concerto. Johannes Moser plays with consummate technique, gorgeous tone, and a rhythmic kick that seems tailor-made for these elegantly crafted pieces. He and his admirable colleague, conductor Fabrice Bollon, launch the First concerto with irresistible verve, and their winsome handling of the slower central episode practically defines the word "charming". They are just as successful in the hardly-less-appealing Second concerto; Moser's double-stopping at the start is immaculately in tune, his articulation in the dashing finale neat as a pin.

The Suite for Cello and Orchestra, in five brief but hugely appealing movements, lasts as long as either of the concertos and ought to be trotted out now and then in concert. Where has this music been? Try the lovely second-movement Serenade, or the delicious Romance. It's not as if there are many such works in the repertoire. The three shorter pieces make perfect encores. Ever notice how much the main theme of the Allegro appassionato resembles (rhythmically at least) the prelude to Carmen? Moser closes the disc with an orchestral arrangement of The Swan, the icing on this positively scrumptious musical cake. The sonics are perfectly balanced and as vivid as the interpretations, while the Stuttgart Orchestra sounds excellent. This is a major release, and Moser is without question an artist worth watching.

Classics Today, David Hurwitz
http://www.classicstoday.com/review.asp?ReviewNum=11969



Goldmark: Piano Quintet Opp 30 & 54
(CPO: 777277-2 )

Goldmark: Piano Quintet Opp 30 & 54

If not for the predominantly square rhythms and repetitive-to-a-fault main theme, you might mistake the full textures and imitative writing in the first movement of Karl Goldmark's 1879 B-flat Piano Quintet for Brahms. Still, a singular compositional voice begins to emerge in the development section's sustained string solos surrounded by rapid piano filigree, as well as in the recapitulation's modulatory twists and turns. The long Adagio begins with a poignant cello feature and gradually gains contrapuntal and expressive complexity as it progresses. Some might liken the Ländler-like Scherzo's obsessive dotted rhythms to those of Schumann; perhaps its earthy melodic charm resonates in more Schubertian terms. If the spirited finale goes on a bit long in proportion to its musical content, the syncopated accents on unresolved chords keep our attention from wandering.

The C-sharp minor Piano Quintet dates from the end of the composer's long life, and it proves a far more interesting, texturally varied, and musically wide-ranging piece, from the first movement's jagged urgency and the Adagio's gorgeously unfolding long lines to the third movement's Hungarian Dance breakouts and the finale's jaunty, narrative drive and weird thematic allusions to "Hail To The Chief".

The Quatuor Sine Nomine members aim for all the tonal variety they can muster in these works, even when both violinists occasionally push their vibratos into cloying territory. The ensemble's kinetic interaction with Oliver Treindl's rock-solid and imaginatively-shaded keyboard work certainly will please collectors who know the pianist's other CPO releases devoted to other chamber rarities of the Romantic Era. As is often the case, CPO's co-production with Bayerischer Rudfunk yields superb sonics, although the German booklet notes' English translation leaves a lot to be desired. Warmly recommended.

Classics Today, Jed Distler
http://www.classicstoday.com/review.asp?ReviewNum=11940



Bruckner: Symphony No. 6
(Haenssler Classic: CD93.219)

Bruckner: Symphony No. 6 Norrington is fearless in the elusive Sixth - this is a great performance

The CD cover shot has Sir Roger Norrington looking at the camera, hands spread wide as if to say “ That’s it,folks .What more do you want ?” Perhaps it was for real. At the end of the performance there’s a sense that the Stuttgart audience can’t quite believe what it’s just heard.

Bruckner’s Sixth has always been the most elusive of the composer’s mature symphonies.Treat it  “ as a kind of music we have never heard before” wrote an admiring Donald Tovey in 1935 . But few have. Only that grand old iconoclast Otto Klemperer, and now Sir Roger, have had the courage  to recognise the piece as an epic off-the-wall revel.

Not that Norrington downplays the symphony’s moments of introspection. No symphony, not even Beethoven’s revel in A, can be a total knees-up. Norrington is aware where the outer movement song-subjects and their attendant harmonic adventures are going to land us. Even more than Klemperer, he takes the main themes of these movements at quite a lick (the finale especially so, at some cost to orchestral equanimity in the lyric countersubject) though as with Klemperer the pulse of the lyrics subjects remains proportionate. Where Norrington is fearless is in Bruckner’s on-the-spot shifts of tempo or key. But, then, he always rather relished the shock of the obvious.

It is difficult to outsmart Klemperer in the Adagio since he too divides his fiddles and deploys minimal vibrato. He is also a touch quicker than Norrington and has a more keenly recorded first oboe. That said, Norrington generates real tension in the harmonically indeterminate climax before the recapitulation. And Norrington’s is more gamesome third movement, the downbeats in the Scherzo’s plodding string ostinato cheekily accented.

So that’s it, folks. With its rustic vigour and devil-may-care insouciance, this is a performance that really does tell it as it is.

Gramophone, Richard Osborne



Kirchner: String Quartets Nos. 1-4
(Albany: TROY1030)

Kirchner: String Quartets Nos. 1-4 A life in quartets from daring early days to age – And still on top form

The  string quartet has been a magnet for composers since the 18th century. It has lost none of its eloquence and suspenseful interaction three centuries later, as this mesmerising recording of Leon Kirchner’s complete quartets richly demonstrates. The American composer explored the medium in the 1940s through the 1960s until he took a four-decade hiatus. His Fourth Quartet dates from 2007, when he was 88.

Kirchner studied with Arnold Schoenberg while absorbing the music of the past and  the surrounding present. In the First Quartet, echoes of Bartok’s revolutionary essays in the form can be heard in the snapping rhythms, haunting conversations, tightly organized structures and string possibilities. The four movements comprise the longest of Kirchner’s  string quartets and they’re explosive harbingers of even more daring creativity.

The Second Quartet is succinct in rhetoric and texture , with thematic connection between movements and sudden shifts of mood that take the ear by surprise. Kirchner acknowledges the impact of electronic music in Quartet No 3, in which the strings go about their skittish or reflective ways as taped sounds occasionally add piquant or ethereal commentary. Unlike many scores of this era, Kirchner’s sounds organic, without intrusive gimmickry.

Forty-one years separate the Third and Fourth quartets, during which Kirchner had a distinguished career at Harvard University and as conductor of contemporary music. The Quartet No 4 summarises his art in the genre, its mixture of yearning and exuberance revealing an octogenarian composer at the top of his game.

The Orion Quartet plays each score as if inhabiting its unique expressive world. The playing is at turns fierce, exquisite and detailed. It would be difficult to imagine Kirchner’s music treated with more loving attention to the introspective and arching aspects of this composer’s compelling art.

Gramophone, Donald Rosenberg.




Bassoon Recital: Hummel; Weber; Berwald; Jacobi; Elgar; Gershwin
(Chandos: CHAN10477)

Bassoon Recital: Hummel; Weber; Berwald; Jacobi; Elgar; Gershwin This is a debut album for the very young bassoonist, Karen Geoghegan. Her  program includes several works in the standard bassoon repertoire–the Hummel Concerto, Carl Maria von Weber’s Andante and Hungarian Rondo, Franz Berwald’s Concert Piece, Carl Heinrich fantastic arrangement of George Gershwin’s ‘Summertime’.

Ms Geoghegan recently was runner up in the BBC 2 Classical Star competition performing the Hummel concerto, which opens her program here. Moreover, her program is an appropriate and respectful debut album; it includes standards and a couple works for the performer to let her hair down. This balance, as opposed to all light or new pieces, identifies a performer as a legitimate participant and willing competitor in the field of performance. It introduces a new musician to listeners and establishes points of reference for the listener or critic with respect to previous performances. Performers who do not  do this eliminate themselves from any ranking or standing.

At 19 year old, she clearly ranks as one of Britain’s top bassoonist; she learned violin starting at the age of 5 and began studying bassoon at 12. An unknowing  listener could not possibly imagine that the performer had only been playing this instrument seven years! She has complete technical mastery of the instrument and very well-developed tone. Even her musicality is advanced. All around, you will want to hear this performance. This would be a mandatory purchase for any of my students.

American Record Guide, David Schwartz




Critics' Picks Archive


2010 2009 2008


Affiliates  |  Classical Points  |  Press Room  |  About Us  |  Contact Us  |  Terms of Use  |  Privacy Policy

Bach   •   Beethoven   •   Handel   •   Mozart   •   Tchaikovsky   •   Vivaldi

ClassicsOnline Newsletter Archive

Monthly Features on ClassicsOnline

ClassicsOnline is your number one source for the newest classical music releases, standards, rarities and bargains from the most popular independent labels, with the largest online classical music catalogue of over 1 Million tracks and more than 50,000 classical music albums available in CD, MP3 (320kbps) and FLAC (lossless format). Recently honored with the 2010 Best Classical Download Site by the MIDEM Classical Awards Jury, ClassicsOnline proves to have a devoted following of classical music enthusiasts and audiophiles worldwide.

ClassicsOnline offers an enormous range of specialist repertoire not available from other classical music online stores. More than 500 new classical music albums are added every month, all at competitive prices. Other notable offerings include: Free preview streaming of every album/track, special advanced search facility enables you to find your favorite classical music composers/artists/works/albums, and DRM-free tracks allows you to ‘burn’ tracks to an unlimited number of CDs or transfer them to an mp3 player or iPod for personal use. Membership is free, and registration includes 5 free tracks for download. Get more free tracks every week and gain access to exclusive classical deals when you subscribe to our newsletter. Enter your email on the left side-bar under newsletter subscription to start getting your weekly free track.
Some titles may not be available in all countries because of possible copyright or licensing restrictions.

Copyright © 2012 Naxos Digital Services Ltd. All rights reserved.
Classicsonline.com – Your Classical Music Download Source
1:26:49 AM May-29-12  -211-