|
|
CHAN10584
HALVORSEN, J.: Orchestral Works, Vol. 1 (Bergen Philharmonic, N. Jarvi)
It's good to see Neeme Järvi back on Chandos, working in top form, and it's even better to see the label starting a new project that promises to be delightfully worthy of collectors' attention and true to its roots in interesting Romantic repertoire. As a composer, Johan Halvorsen (1864-1935) is seriously underestimated, largely because most of his orchestral music falls into the category of theater or "incidental" music. A good bit of it, and much else besides, has been recorded by Simax, but those discs may be difficult to find (and costly too). It is, in any case, often music of very high quality, as the suite from Mascarade (same story as Nielsen's opera) clearly reveals.
The First Symphony, which dates from the 1920s but could have been written three or four decades earlier, reveals Halvorsen's ties to the school of the Russian "Mighty Five". If you enjoy, say, Borodin's Second, then you're going to love this immaculately crafted, tuneful, and melodically memorable piece. The other three pieces are brief "pops" numbers, but no less attractive or well-made. In short, there's not a note here unworthy of your time and attention, even the tiny La Mélancolie, an arrangement of an earlier tune by Ole Bull. As already noted, Järvi is back to his old exciting, vigorous self, and the orchestra plays with total commitment and enthusiasm. Great sound too. A terrific release. [6/18/2010] ---David Hurwitz
Read more...
|
|
|
|
8.554842
SCARLATTI, D.: Keyboard Sonatas (Complete), Vol. 7
Konstantin Scherbakov approaches Scarlatti from a pianistic perspective in that he draws upon the instrument's infinite capacity for tone color and dynamic shading for maximum musical effect. His extraordinary sense of timing and wide variety of articulations hold attention in slow, texturally spare works like the F major K. 542 and F minor K. 238 sonatas (the gorgeously calibrated diminuendos in the latter will take your breath away). His scales and ornaments are unfailingly alive, pinpointed, and peppered with rhythmic sparkle, as in the C major K. 422 (whose melodic surprises foreshadow Haydn), the heel-clicking F major K. 17, and D major K. 313 sonatas.
Lyrical pieces, such as the achingly eloquent G major K. 283, also benefit from Scherbakov's imagination, taste, and technical finish. I wouldn't hesitate to enshrine Scherbakov alongside the great Scarlatti pianists on disc, including Horowitz, Pletnev, Meyer, Tipo, and Schiff. Yes, he's that good! The excellent engineering gives the piano a slightly metallic edge, and the bass has great richness without exaggeration. This is the finest release thus far in Naxos' ongoing complete Scarlatti sonata cycle. [2/28/2005] --Jed Distler
Read more...
|
|
|
|
8.572392
SHOSTAKOVICH, D.: Symphonies, Vol. 3 - Symphony No. 8 (Royal Liverpool Philharmonic, Petrenko)
This may not be the most harrowing version of the Eighth, but of its type it's unquestionably a great performance. Often this symphony consists of hair-raising climaxes interspersed between acres of nothingness. Not here. This symphony also is one of Shostakovich's most formally masterly and imaginative, and this performance reminds us in the most compelling way. Petrenko's flowing tempos in the first movement and passacaglia keep the music moving, not lurching, forward at all times. The 25 minutes of the first movement seem to pass by in half that time. Its opening threnody in particular has even more expressive power than usual for being phrased in long melodic arcs that never turn static.
After an aptly gawky scherzo, the toccata is as brilliant and menacing as any (with a dashingly militant central section), but it's the finale that really sets the seal on this performance. The Eighth always is a tough piece to project convincingly, but Petrenko is at his absolute best here, pacing the music perfectly and timing the climax in such a way that (for once) it doesn't sound like a less impressive recapitulation of the first movement--and this isn't because its previous occurrence is underplayed in any way. Excellent playing from all departments of the orchestra plus vividly natural engineering complete what is easily the best installment of this ongoing cycle to date. [6/10/2010] --David Hurwitz
Read more...
|
|
|
|
GCD921112
BACH, J.S.: Mass in B minor, BWV 232 (Bruggen)
For some performers these days, rendering of Bach's choral works comes down to a numbers game: from the most basic cantata to the most elaborate passion setting--or the B minor Mass--they claim Bach intended his choral works to be sung by only one voice to a part. Period. And because with modern performers of the highest professional caliber and recording techniques that easily present performances by singers and orchestra in ideal balance and optimal acoustic perspective they are able to demonstrate the feasibility of their theory, they hopefully declare their case closed. And while this theory--most diligently researched and avidly advocated by Joshua Rifkin--is certainly worthy and deserving of respectful attention, all you have to do is listen to a performance such as this superb one from Frans Brüggen and his Cappella Amsterdam and Orchestra of the 18th Century and you must conclude that, no, Bach may have had to accept minimal forces for his big choral works, but his conception clearly was on a grander scale--and anyone who understands the mentality of composers in the face of often unfair and unreasonable real-world constraints, both economic and artistic, knows that they never let the purely practical or necessary get in the way of the ideal (think Beethoven's piano sonatas, for example).
Brüggen is a long-time master of Baroque performance, and here he shows that mastery at every level, from the perfectly judged tempos to the dynamic choral movements, sensitively shaped arias, rich textural detail, and overall sense of balance between orchestra and chorus, chorus and solo or duetto movements, and orchestra with whatever configuration of vocal forces. The result is a grandly-scaled performance that feels neither long nor labored--and the contributions by all concerned--soloists, choir, and orchestra--are first-rate. Large works such as this, containing so many variables, usually have one or more weak links--an inadequate soloist or two, undernourished orchestral playing, disappointing sound--but no apologies are necessary here. This recording, from a concert performance in Warsaw, Poland in 2009, easily tops my list and reassures me that not only do I not have to accept a flawed performance of this masterpiece (check out the other reviews in our archive), but I--and we--can happily reject any notion of bare-bones Bach in favor of a conception that fully realizes the spiritual power and interpretive possibilities inherent in this much-discussed and debated score. Excellent notes explaining the history of the work and the origin of this recording enhance this outstanding release. [6/4/2010] --David Vernier
Read more...
|
|
|
|
8.559380
SCHOENFIELD, P.: Refractions / 6 British Folk Songs / Peccadilloes (Tocco, Hanani, Fiterstein, Schoenfield)
Paul Schoenfield's music blends accessible modernism with sophisticated wit built on a solid foundation of popular, jazz, and Jewish sources, all of which are in evidence in this splendid recording of his chamber music. The title piece, Refractions, is a trio for piano, clarinet, and cello, its four movements based on music from Mozart's The Marriage of Figaro. But the work doesn't follow the familiar pattern of paraphrase and variation; rather, as the title suggests, it's a convoluted take on the opera's arias and recitatives, the source references often barely discernible even to knowledgeable opera buffs.
The opening Toccata, for example, is based on the opera's Overture, which is barely alluded to; what sticks in the mind is a lively Hassidic wedding tune. The March movement, based on "Non piu andrai", hints at Prokofiev, and the final Tarantella reminds this listener of ragtime and the musical accompaniments to a Charlie Chaplin short as much as it does to "Se vuol bailare". But such eclecticism is what helps to make the piece so laden with surprises and listening excitement.
Schoenfield exploits the harmonic and timbral possibilities of the instrumental combinations such as the unison clarinet/cello in the opening Toccata, and varies the instrumental spotlight to focus on the clarinet cadenza in the Intermezzo, followed by brief solos by the cello and piano. So if Mozart's hard to discern here, Schoenfield's individual voice is welcome compensation.
Peccadilloes refers to Rossini's title for his late piano pieces, Sins of My Old Age, and the melodies of each of its six movements are inspired by, as Schoenfield writes in the disc's notes, "what is generally considered bad taste or inferior culture." He advises listening with "the same sort of guilt and pleasure that accompany one while eating a large chocolate sundae." But Peccadilleos is a lot more than that--it's a virtuoso piano work that pays homage to great composers and musicians such as Ravel, Gershwin, and the Harlem stride pianists of the 1920s. James Tucco shines here, playing with technicolor sheen in the Gershwinesque Allemande, whose melody parodies the music of old Hollywood romantic comedies, while conveying the excitement of the galloping rhythms and high spirits of the final movement, Boogie.
The disc opens with Six British Folk Songs for cello and piano, a tribute to Jacqueline du Pré. Cellist Yehuda Hanani's rich tone sings the familiar melodies fluently, investing Schoenfield's elaborations on them with soulful poignancy in The Gypsy Laddie and virtuoso dynamism in The Lousy Tailor. This disc is a sheer delight from the first note to the last. [6/8/2010] --Dan Davis
Read more...
|
|
|
|
BIS-CD-1677
TAMBERG, E.: Joanna Tentata Suite / Symphonic Dances / Concerto grosso (Hague Residentie Orchestra, N. Jarvi)
Estonian composer Eino Tamberg (b. 1930) is the real deal--a composer with a fresh take on traditional tonal music who knows how to write tunes and score them with unfailing color and point. His Concerto Grosso--for flute, trumpet, clarinet, alto saxophone, bassoon, piano, harp, strings, and percussion--is a masterpiece of 20th century neo-classicism and it deserves to be a repertory item. It dates from 1956 and at only Op. 5 it announces a major talent. The Symphonic Dances arrived a year later and fall within similar stylistic parameters, from the opening tune that has a Poulenc-like wit, to the three saxophones that give Tamberg's scoring a truly modern feel.
If you had the chance to hear Tamberg's 1976 opera Cyrano de Bergerac (and if you didn't, get it--it's on CPO), then you already know that he has a wonderful feeling for the theater, and for writing dramatic music. The ballet Joanna Tentata is based on the same source that gave us Penderecki's opera The Devils of Loudon. Now let's face it, stories about demonic possession in a convent have lots of juicy potential, as well as a long history on the stage, going back through Prokofiev's The Fiery Angel to Meyerbeer's Robert le Diable. Tamberg's ballet suite instantly establishes the story's haunted setting (church bells leading to a big, dissonant instrumental pileup), but the music at the same time celebrates and positively reeks of the dance. And once again we can only applaud Tamberg's willingness (and ability) to write a good tune.
Believe it or not, some of this music has been recorded previously. The Concerto Grosso appeared on a difficult-to-source Antes CD in a very fine performance by Estonian forces. This new version is wonderful too, even more naturally recorded, and Neeme Järvi is just the conductor for this colorful, exciting, and strongly gestural music. The musicians of the Residentie Orkest also clearly relish Tamberg's ebullient musical personality and the opportunities he gives them to shine. We can only hope that BIS will delve more deeply into Tamberg's output and help to bring him some of the international attention he surely deserves. [6/1/2010] --David Hurwitz
Read more...
|
|
|
|
8.559677
WHITACRE, E.: Choral Music (Elora Festival Singers, Edison)
Eric Whitacre's choral works have been generously surveyed on disc, but only a handful of choirs have yet devoted an entire recording to his music. He couldn't have more luminous or illuminating interpreters than the Elora Festival Singers, a choir that I've heartily praised in the past and that deserves the same recognition here. Although there is much duplication, this program makes a fine companion to the 2005 recording by Polyphony (Hyperion) that I previously recommended (type Q9718 in Search Reviews).
Missing from the Hyperion disc but included among the 11 selections here is the rarely recorded "little tree", a sparkling, brightly sonorous setting with piano of e.e. cummings' sweetly childlike Christmas poem that contains a couple of musical quotes from what could be the song Gesu Bambino (or perhaps the Sussex carol?) and ends with spectacular multiple bursts of dazzling Whitacre-esque harmony. Also found here but not on the Hyperion recording (which incidentally features more selections altogether--14) are Little Birds, a setting of a poem by Octavio Paz--also with piano and containing some striking, non-sung vocal sounds!, and the wild and fascinating (also rarely recorded) Leonardo Dreams of His Flying Machine, an imaginative scenario with text by C.A. Silvestri.
The rest of the disc is filled with first-rate performances of Whitacre's most popular works, from A Boy and a Girl and Water Night to Lux aurumque and Sleep. Although not mentioned in the notes, the music for this last piece originally was written to the famous Robert Frost poem, Stopping by woods on a snowy evening, but had to be radically revised when the Frost Estate inexplicably refused to grant permission for a musical setting (in spite of numerous existing ones!). Whitacre and his poetic collaborator ingeniously solved the problem (although the Frost poem still fits neatly into the musical framework) and in the process created one of the composer's best-loved and most evocative works.
And speaking of liner notes, they focus almost exclusively on trying to explain Whitacre's compositional style, discussing in a somewhat technical fashion intervals and harmonic relationships, polychords, subdominants, mediant triads, etc. While some listeners will certainly appreciate this analytical detail, I believe most would have preferred to simply have the texts (which are not included!) and some information on the origin of the pieces and the relationships between the music and the poetry. Not having the texts at hand for a program of vocal or choral music is a significant drawback and detracts from full enjoyment of the listening experience.
Although I haven't changed my mind about the "too-long-for-its-material" handicap of the 13-minute When David Heard, the setting of e.e. cummings' "i thank you God for most this amazing day" is truly a masterpiece of choral writing and of musical embodiment of the tone and meaning of the poetry. And the Elora singers certainly "get it", as they do all the rest of the music on the program. The sound, from the choir's home venue in Elora, Ontario, exemplifies the consistently fine efforts of engineer Norbert Kraft and producer Bonnie Silver. Highly recommended. [5/28/2010] --David Vernier
Read more...
|
|
|
|
ODE1157-2
LINDBERG, M.: Graffiti / Seht die Sonne (Helsinki Chamber Choir, Finnish Radio Symphony, Oramo)
Graffiti (2009) is Magnus Lindberg's first major choral work, indeed one of his few ventures in vocal writing, and it's wonderful. Lasting about half an hour, the text consists of advertisements, scribbling, and the usual scatological commentary found on your typical city walls, only here the language is Latin, and the walls belonged to Pompeii before its annihilation in an eruption of Mt. Vesuvius. The best way to enjoy the piece is to read the text first (helpfully printed with English translations in the booklet), then simply listen as the music evokes the variegated moods and activities of an ancient city literally dancing on the edge of destruction.
Stylistically, Graffiti is one of Lindberg's most tonally oriented pieces, not just because he uses modal harmony to give the music a certain primal, even barbaric splendor, but also (I like to hope) because he has realized that more than 30 minutes of continuous music benefits from having strong tonal underpinnings. And even the most virtuosic singers (the Helsinki Chamber Choir is certainly that) benefit from having traditional melodies and harmonies to assist in projecting the text. In short, Graffiti is as intelligent as it is beautiful, appealing, and exciting, and its less obviously modernist style certainly does not represent a retrenchment on Lindberg's part, but rather an adaptation of his personal idiom to the music's expressive demands.
Seht die Sonne (2007) for some reason takes its title from the final chorus of Schoenberg's Gurrelieder. I truly don't get the modern need to find cute titles for new works--Lindberg could have called it "Contraption 43" for all that it matters--but like Graffiti this is an absolutely bewitching piece of orchestral writing. Once again the mixture of tonal and textural elements creates a compelling musical tapestry, with moments of really powerful beauty and expressive intensity. I'm thinking particularly of the transition between the first and second movements, with its voluptuous violin writing, as well as the last several minutes of the entire work (its three movements run together without a break). As already suggested, the performances are vivid, even thrilling, the engineering outstandingly lifelike and (in Graffiti especially) well-balanced. Hot stuff! --David Hurwitz
Read more...
|
|
|
|
AV2188
RACHMANINOV, S.: Symphonic Dances / The Isle of the Dead / The Rock (Royal Liverpool Philharmonic, Petrenko)
This is a perfectly planned Rachmaninov orchestral music CD, offering works that span his entire career, from his first major orchestral piece, the Tchaikovskian tone poem The Rock, to his fully characteristic maturity in The Isle of the Dead, and culminating in the instrumental sophistication and hard-edged glitter of his last big project, the Symphonic Dances. Happily, the performances are just as wonderful as the programming concept.
Vasily Petrenko digs deep into the Symphonic Dances right from the initial outburst. He seems to have figured out the first movement's puzzling "non allegro" marking particularly well, finding a bracing tempo that doesn't compromise rhythmic accent. The second-movement waltz features an amazing range of tempo within a phrase, but Petrenko never sounds mannered or loses the pulse. The finale blazes, particularly in the closing pages, while the moody central interlude never sags. Through it all the orchestra plays magnificently: velvet strings, clean and clear winds, powerful brass, and crisp percussion.
The two tone poems are just as fine. The Rock (just which rock Rachmaninov had in mind we're not quite sure) seldom has sounded so confident and cohesive (as well as exciting), but this version of The Isle of the Dead really is special. Check out the pulverizing return of the main theme, forte, about nine minutes in, or the devastatingly intense final climax followed by the numb muttering of the "Dies irae" chant melody in the strings. It's exhausting and exhilarating at the same time, helped in no small degree by really excellent sonics that let the strings soar and the bass frequencies really throb. None of this music lacks for excellent performances, but you'd be hard pressed to find demonstrably superior versions of any of these pieces gathered together on a single disc. --David Hurwitz
Read more...
|
|
|
|
ONYX4044
PAGANINI, N.: 24 Caprices, Op. 1 (Ehnes)
This eminently popular and extremely challenging set of works for virtuoso solo violin naturally has attracted the interest of every major artist worthy of the name, resulting in a significant recorded legacy that's as much a tribute to the artists--Accardo, Perlman, Rabin, Ricci, Midori, etc.--as to Paganini's genius. However, if you're in the market for a first-rank--indeed superlative--recording of Paganini's masterpiece, look no further than this release from Canadian violinist James Ehnes.
While Ehnes may not readily embrace the "superstar" emblem, he is as deserving of that status as anyone, and not because his publicist and record company have declared it. He is simply a phenomenal violinist and extraordinary musician who, from the first bars of Caprice No. 1 commands your attention and never lets it wander through the next 75 or so minutes.
Unlike some violinists whose aim is simply to call attention to their dazzling technique and charismatic musicianship (which Ehnes has in spades!), as you listen to Ehnes, there's never a hint of exploitation--he's all business, all about the fire and passion in Paganini's outrageously extroverted signatures. And his technique is so smooth, so natural, you are not distracted by noticing such mundane, human impairments as physical effort, nor do you fail to appreciate his gifts for tonal allure and sheer dramatic flair--Paganini's technical obstacles are, well, just not obstacles at all. And that's just how it should be in these works, a tribute to the composer's uninhibited style and unfettered understanding of what the violin--and a skilled violinist--can do.
A critical observer easily can go through and dissect each one of the 24 caprices and judge Ehnes' approach relative to other benchmarks--but as far as I'm concerned, playing of this caliber stands on its own, apart from comparisons, no matter how judicious or thoughtful. Ehnes' performances are solid enough and authoritative enough that you can confidently choose this recording as your reference--and as a guaranteed, bedazzling journey through some of the violin repertoire's most awesome terrain. Highly recommended! [4/21/2010] --David Vernier
Read more...
|
|