Review By Adrian Corleonis ,Fanfare,November 2010
Delius was not at home with sonata form, resorting to it early and late as a very loose frame for his essentially rhapsodic thoughts, and each of the violin sonatas has its performance pitfalls—repetition devolving into longueurs, unevenness of inspiration, a wandering trajectory unresolved by sudden flourishes at the ends of movements, and so on. The Sonata in B, composed in 1892—that is, Delius at his greenest—vamps its improvisatory “finds” in a search for another inspired rush. Tasmin Little (Conifer 51315, Fanfare 22:1), with Piers Lane hand-in-glove, teeters between impetuosity and impatience, substituting élan for formal coherence, where Susanne Stanzeleit and Gusztáv Fenyo, in giving Delius’s lyricism its honeyed due, wander. In the numbered sonatas, Stanzeleit and Little are closely matched in sensitivity, milking the wonderstruck moments into mellifluous ennui. Little wins by a little—her tone is sweeter. Even in the Third Sonata, the shapeliest of them, this maundering, far from revealing expressive riches, smoothes Delius’s snap and swagger—his scherzando—in a prolonged tedium shown up by more highly inflected performances, for instance, in the Third, that by Alexander Barantschik, and in the First and Second, by Janice Graham, both winningly partnered by Israela Margalit (EMI 55399). But such comparisons are unfair to the artists; if the album jacket may be believed, Stanzeleit and Fenyo recorded these works in February 1994, and one may well wonder why we’re hearing them only now and what the artists’ spin on them might be today. Balance is excellent, neither instrument crowding the other, nor are they in the porches of your ears, though sound is detailed and rich. On a PC the program comes up in kanji.