This is Inkinen’s second Sibelius collection for Naxos; I praised the first in Fanfare, and if anything, like the present one even better.
At first, the programming of this disc seems somewhat arbitrary; it combines some of Sibelius’s most obscure tone poems—one long, the others quite brief—with two sets of excerpts from his incidental music. The Kuolema music isn’t an actual suite, but rather two pairs of short pieces written for different productions, thus the two opus numbers. But upon listening to the disc, I recognized the logic behind the choice of repertoire: all of these works were composed between 1903 and 1911—that is, during the transitional period that includes the Third Symphony. The Romantic language of the first two symphonies is definitively left behind, but the more spartan style of the Fourth has yet to emerge. In contrast, the earlier disc featured mostly works from Sibelius’s “patriotic” period, immediately preceding the turn of the century.
Night Ride and Sunrise used to be a rarity on record; it is still probably the least-played of Sibelius’s major tone poems. It can easily turn tedious in the wrong hands (it’s a long ride!), and Inkinen skirts danger by taking one of the slowest tempos on disc, but the pulse throughout the first part remains firm, the woodwind solos in the middle section carry easily over the strings—even the piccolo-bass clarinet duets are audible—and the orchestra makes a lovely sound in the Sunrise section…The suite from Belshazzar’s Feast features some lovely playing, particularly by solo violin and cello in the second movement, “Solitude,” and by solo flute in the third, “Night Music.” But the opening “Oriental Procession” really needs more prominent percussion…In the Kuolema music, the “Valse triste” is languorous, perhaps too much so, but most collectors can afford a change-of-pace version of this once-ubiquitous work. The remaining movements are done well, although I find the “Canzonetta” perhaps a notch too slow.
The shorter works, mostly atmospheric in character, are colorfully done, their effect aided by the immediacy of the recording and the high quality of the solo woodwind-playing. Indeed, the New Zealand Symphony has a major-orchestra sound, and the recording is splendid throughout. Naxos doesn’t tell us what the venue is, but it’s a good one; the sound is both full and unusually transparent.
This program may not be top-drawer Sibelius, but it does include a number of delicious miniatures in top-notch performances. It seems likely that we’ll have more Sibelius from Inkinen; it’s a prospect I await eagerly. Recommended.