Review By David Denton, Naxos,June 2008
This is the sixth and final volume of the American recordings made by Andres Segovia in New York in the 1950’s. Born in Andalusia in 1893, he found that his love of the guitar soon took him past the technique of available mentors, and could only continue by teaching himself. He was to become the father of the modern guitar world, establishing a virtuosity that others have since emulated. In making the guitar more fashionable, Segovia had to resort to transcriptions of works that audiences would recognise, and he did not have the mass of original compositions that today’s performers enjoy. The first part of the present disc is Segovia’s arrangement of piano pieces and songs by Schumann, Franck, Brahms, Grieg and Scriabin, some more successful than others. The remainder includes the Sonatina by Torroba, Etudes and Preludes by Villa-Lobos and Manuel de Falla’s only score for solo guitar, Homenaje, ‘Le Tombeau de Claude Debussy’. That the early part of the disc often sounds so uninspired comes as a surprise, as Segovia must have oft used the works in concert. Even Grieg’s Melody from the Lyric Pieces is lumpy and lacking in shape. It comes as a relief to reach track 7, Miguel Llobet’s El Mestre, where the music and the instrument sit happily together. From therein the disc is well worth having, as we have over sixty minutes of guitar magic, and includes one of the instrument’s most haunting melodies in Villa-Lobos’s First Prelude. Already turned sixty, Segovia was having better days than others, but was on top form for Torroba’s Sonatina, getting around the mercurial passages with an easy brilliance. The original recordings were made by Decca between 1952 and 1956, and issued in Europe on the Brunswick label. Alan Bunting’s restoration is another piece of Naxos excellence, though he cannot do anything with Manen’s Fantasia-Sonata in a dreadful December 1956 session and seemingly never internationally released. more....
|