Review By David Denton, Naxos,February 2007
Though Naxos is marketing this as a work by Handel, it is in fact a pastiche
by John Christopher Smith who 'borrowed' music from Handel�s operas, oratorios
and other works. I suppose you would kindly describe Smith as an 'opportunist',
who finding he had inherited Handel's scores from his father - who had acted
as the composer's copyist - was not slow in using them for his own financial
gain. He enlisted the help of Thomas Morell to supply a suitable libretto to
fit the chosen music, and used various sources in creating the musical story.
It relates the legend of the pious and steadfast Tobit (Tobias the elder) who
becomes blind and sends his son also called Tobit to collect money owed. A guiding
hand passes him through trials and tribulations until he arrives back home able
to cure his father's blindness, and everyone lives happily thereafter. It is
a quite extensive score of similar length to Messiah, Smith, offering
a semblance of creativity, adding the music for recitatives. He was not shy
of cherry-picking from works that would have been popular at the time, the score
opening with the overture to the opera, Tamerlano. Today most of the
works have fallen from the repertoire, and we might even show gratitude to Smith
for his recycling act. Sung in English - I think - by an international cast
from both sides of the Atlantic, and I am vocally impressed by the Canadian
soprano, Linda Perillo, a singer specialising in this era, and by the tenor,
Knut Schoch, an expert in Baroque performance. Maya Boog is at times troubled
in fast decorative passages, and after an early period of edgy intonation, Barbara
Hannigan settles into a pleasing light voice. The Choir sounds fresh and energetic,
while the Frankfurt Baroque produces that sound we would have heard in Handel's
time. There are few mishaps in the one 'live' performance that gave rise to
the recording made in 2001, the sound quite close but with a warm ambience.
This is the only available recording. more....
|