ClassicsOnline Home » BUXTEHUDE, D.: Harpsichord Music, Vol. 3 (Mortensen)
Born fifty years after Heinrich Schütz, the ‘father of German music’, and little less than half a century before J. S. Bach, Dietrich Buxtehude provided a link between the founder of Protestant Baroque music and its greatest master. While Buxtehude's organ music is comparatively well known, his harpsichord music has attracted less attention. The third volume of the present series includes two Suites of French dances and the brilliant series of variations on an aria under the title La Capricciosa.
By Giv Cornfield
The New Recordings, Cliffs Classics
Bach gets all the credit, but Buxtehude (and Schütz before him) had 'been there' before. This is the third in the series of a planned traversal of all of Buxtehude's works for harpsichord. It's another winner: the music is simply great, and Mortensen's mastery and consummate stylistic insight are a joy. Dates and location are given in great detail, but not a word about the magnificent-sounding instrument he plays.
By David Denton
Lars Ulrik Mortensen’s self-effacing musicianship is placed at the service of Dietrich Buxtehude’s harpsichord music, a composer who is becoming better recognised outside of the organ repertoire.
He may well have been born in Denmark, his early life sketchily chronicled until we encounter his presence as organist in Lubeck, an appointment that would have given him considerable sway in the development of music in Germany. He seldom states the instrument to be used so that speculation exists as to Buxtehude’s original intentions, Mortensen’s series offering his own idea as to the extent of his harpsichord output. Certainly the Suites—the A major (BuxWV 243) and F major (BuxWV 238) which are included on this disc—have the intimate feel that would indicate domestic use, while the extended set of Thirty-two Variations, subtitled ‘La Capricciosa’, are a series of dances ill-fitted for church use. The Prelude in G major (BuxWV 162) would be more open to doubt, for here the music seems well suited, both in texture and mood, to the organ. The performances were previously available on the Marco Polo label, and led to Mortensen being named Danish Musician of the Year in 2000. His playing is a model of clarity and elegance, tempos keeping the music flowing, phrases shaped with good period taste. The recording is of superb quality.
Dietrich Buxtehude (1637–1707)
Harpsichord Music • 3
Dietrich Buxtehude was most likely born in 1637 in the Danish town of Helsingborg, now part of Sweden. His father Johannes (Hans), also an organist, had immigrated to Denmark at an unknown time from Oldesloe in Holstein. In the year 1641 Johannes Buxtehude was employed as the organist at St Mary’s Church, Helsingborg, and soon after that he moved across the Øresund to become organist of St Olai Church in Helsingør. The exact date of Dietrich’s birth is unknown, but at the time of his death on 9 May 1707, he was said to be about seventy years old.
The knowledge of Latin that Buxtehude displayed in later life indicates that he must have attended a Latin school as a boy. Although he undoubtedly began his organ studies with his father, further information concerning his teachers is totally lacking. Other possible teachers in Denmark include Claus Dengel, organist at St Mary’s, Helsingør, from 1650 to 1660, and the younger Johann Lorentz, the famous organist at St Nicholas’s Church in Copenhagen from 1634 until his death in 1689. Lorentz was a pupil and son-in-law of Jacob Praetorius in Hamburg, and the Buxtehude family made his acquaintance in 1650 upon the death of his father, an organ builder. Buxtehude might later have studied with Heinrich Scheidemann in Hamburg or Franz Tunder in Lübeck.
In late 1657 or early 1658, Buxtehude took up the same position as organist of St Mary’s Church, Helsingborg, that his father had occupied before coming to Helsingør. He worked there until October 1660, when he became organist of St Mary’s, Helsingør, called the German church because it served foreigners of the community and the military garrison of Kronborg. In Helsingør Buxtehude was expected to play at the beginning of the service while the pastor was robing himself; he and the cantor were to provide instrumental and vocal music for the church on feast days and at other times at the pastor’s request.
The position of organist and Werkmeister at St Mary’s, Lübeck, became vacant upon the death of Franz Tunder on 5 November 1667, and Dietrich Buxtehude was formally appointed the following April. This was a much more prestigious and well paid position than the one he had held in Helsingør; Buxtehude was the most highly paid musician in Lübeck, and he earned nearly as much as the pastor of St Mary’s.
Buxtehude swore the oath of citizenship on 23 July 1668, enabling him to marry Anna Margarethe Tunder, a daughter of his predecessor, on 3rd August, 1668. Of seven daughters born to the couple three died in infancy, a fourth survived to early adulthood, and three remained in the household at the time of Buxtehude’s death. Godparents to the Buxtehude children came from the higher strata of Lübeck society. Buxtehude himself belonged to the fourth social class, however, together with lesser wholesalers, retailers and brewers. In inviting his social superiors to serve as godparents, and in some cases naming his children after them, Buxtehude was also cultivating their patronage for his musical enterprises.
As organist of St Mary’s, Buxtehude’s chief responsibility lay in playing the organ for the main morning and afternoon services on Sundays and feast days. He also held the position of Werkmeister of St Mary’s, the administrator and treasurer of the church, a position of considerable responsibility and prestige. The account books that he kept in this capacity document the life of the church and its music in considerable detail. The cantor of St Mary’s, also a teacher at the Catharineum, held the responsibility for providing the liturgical music, using his school choir of men and boys. They performed together with most of the Lübeck municipal musicians from a large choir-loft in the front of the church, over the rood screen. Two municipal musicians, a violinist and a lutenist, regularly performed with Buxtehude from the large organ.
Buxtehude inherited a tradition established by Franz Tunder of performing concerts from the large organ of St Mary’s at the request of the business community. Tunder had gradually added vocalists and instrumentalists to his organ performances, which are said to have taken place on Thursdays prior to the opening of the stock exchange. Within a year of his arrival in Lübeck, Buxtehude had greatly expanded the possibilities for the performance of concerted music from the large organ by having two new balconies installed at the west end of the church, each paid for by a single donor. These new balconies, together with the four that were already there, could accommodate about forty singers and instrumentalists. Buxtehude called his concerts Abendmusiken and changed the time of their presentation to Sundays after vespers. In time these concerts took place regularly on the last two Sundays after Trinity and the second, third and fourth Sundays of Advent each year. By 1678 he had introduced the practice of presenting oratorios of his own composition in serial fashion on these Sundays. He also directed performances of concerted music from the large organ during the regular church services, although this activity, like the presentation of the Abendmusiken, lay outside his official duties to the church.
By 1703 Buxtehude had served for 35 years as organist of St Mary’s; he was about 66 years old and he was no doubt concerned about the future of his three unmarried daughters, so he began to look for a successor who would marry the eldest, now 28. The first prospective candidates of whom we know were Johann Mattheson and Georg Frideric Handel, both of whom were employed at the Hamburg opera at the time. They travelled to Lübeck together on 17 August 1703 and listened to Buxtehude “with dignified attention”, but since neither of them was at all interested in the marriage condition, they returned to Hamburg the following day. Johann Sebastian Bach made his famous trip to visit Buxtehude in the autumn of 1705, coinciding with the Abendmusik season, and he remained in Lübeck for nearly three months. Bach, too, may have been interested in obtaining the succession to Buxtehude’s position, but there is no evidence that this was the case. The account of the trip in Bach’s obituary states unambiguously that its purpose was to hear Buxtehude play the organ, and in his report to the Arnstadt consistory upon his return the following February, Bach stated that he had made the trip “in order to comprehend one thing and another about his art”. Buxtehude died on 9 May 1707 and was succeeded by Johann Christian Schieferdecker, who married Buxtehude’s eldest daughter on 5 September 1707.
Keyboard music of the seventeenth century was not usually designated for particular instruments, and most of it could be played on organ, harpsichord, or clavichord. The manuscripts that transmit Buxtehude’s keyboard music, however, generally restrict themselves to one of three types of music that can indeed be associated with particular instruments: free works such as praeludia and toccatas, many of them designated “pedaliter ”, and thus for organ; settings of German chorales, most of them also requiring the pedal; and a distinctly secular repertoire consisting of dance suites and variations, presumably for harpsichord. These boundaries are by no means rigid, however, and this series of recordings exploits such fluidity by drawing from all three genres for its programmes.
Nearly all of Buxtehude’s suites and variations on secular tunes are preserved in a single Danish manuscript, now at the Royal Library in Copenhagen, which contains the history of the Ryge family reading in one direction and a collection of keyboard music, mainly by Buxtehude, in the other. The musical portion was probably copied early in the eighteenth century. The fact that two of the suites attributed to Buxtehude in this manuscript were actually composed by Nicolas-Antoine Lebègue underlines the stylistic similarity of the German keyboard suite to French models, particularly in the use of stile brisé, which the French clavecinistes had adapted from lute music. The standardisation of the movements to Allemande, Courante, Sarabande, and Gigue, however, can be credited to German composers.
The two suites offered here present the intimate, domestic aspect of Buxtehude’s keyboard art. In each case the allemande is the weightiest element, “the proposition in a musical suite, from which the corrente, sarabande and gique [sic] flow as parts”, in the words of Buxtehude’s grandstudent Martin Heinrich Fuhrmann. Indeed, the openings of Buxtehude’s correnti often follow the melodic contour of the allemande, and in the case of the F major suite, BuxWV 238, the corrente approaches an actual variation of it. The Ryge manuscript usually spells this movement “Courent“ in a curious mixture of French and Italian; in fact Buxtehude usually follows the Italian corrente, with its lightly running quaver motion, rather than the more subtle French courante. Fuhrmann characterizes the Sarabande as an “instrumental aria, usually eight measures, going slowly in triple”, and this is the shortest and simplest movement of a Buxtehude suite. The gigues in Buxtehude’s suites have a more contrapuntal texture than the other movements, but they are not strictly fugal, usually dissolving into homophony after a few entrances. It is through the gigue, however, that the dance makes itself most strongly felt in the other genres of Buxtehude’s keyboard music.
Each of Buxtehude’s three variation sets is grounded in dance rhythms. His most famous variation set, labelled Aria , but subtitled La Capricciosa, BuxWV 250, follows the Bergamasca, a dance that originated in Italy during the sixteenth century and was widespread throughout Europe in the seventeenth. Its first half also appears as the Thuringian song Kraut und Rüben that J.S. Bach used in the quodlibet concluding the Goldberg Variations, BWV988, but it is unlikely that Buxtehude knew it in this form. Bach may have known La Capricciosa, on the other hand, since, like his Goldberg Variations, it is a virtuoso showpiece consisting of 32 variations on an aria in G major. In La Capricciosa Buxtehude layers dance upon dance, changing the simple duple metre of the Bergamasca to that of a gigue (Partite 9 and 19), a sarabande (Partita 25), and a minuet (Partite 29 and 30).
Buxtehude’s free keyboard works, those independent of a preexisting melody or dance pattern, are mainly transmitted in manuscripts that include both pedaliter and manualiter works. Among these, his most original and justly famous works are praeludia and toccatas in the stylus phantasticus, which intermingles highly unpredictable free sections in virtuosic and idiomatic keyboard styles with more structured fugal sections. Since organists naturally prefer the pedaliter works, those for manuals alone are much less frequently performed, thus offering rich opportunities to adventurous harpsichordists. Even in these free works one can find elements of dance and variation. In the Prelude in G major, BuxWV162, the second fugue is a variation, in gigue rhythm, of the first. Buxtehude may have conceived his canzonas as teaching pieces; they are all manualiter works, and students most often practised on the clavichord or harpsichord. They are variously titled canzon, canzonet, or fuga and consist either of a single fugue or of three related fugues, as in BuxWV168, in the manner of the variation canzona inherited from Frescobaldi and Froberger. Friedrich Wilhelm Marpurg, in his Abhandlung von der Fuge (1753), used the third fugue of BuxWV 168 as an illustration of a counter fugue, in which the answer moves in contrary motion to the subject.
Abridged from a note by Kerala Snyder, 1998
Last Albums Viewed
BUXTEHUDE, D.: Harpsichord Music, Vol. 3 (Mortense...