Jean Sibelius (1865-1957):
Violin Concerto in D minor, Op. 47 • Serenade in G minor, Op. 69b
Christian Sinding (1856-1941):
Violin Concerto in A major, Op. 45 • Romance in D major, Op. 100
The Finnish composer Jean Sibelius was born in 1865,
the son of a doctor, in a small town in the south of
Finland, the language and culture of his family being
Swedish. It was at school that he was to learn Finnish
and acquire his first interest in the early legends of a
country that had become an autonomous grand-duchy
under the Tsar of Russia, after the defeat of Charles XII
of Sweden. Throughout the later nineteenth century
there were divisions between the Swedish-speaking
upper classes and the Finnish-speaking people, the
cause of the latter embraced by influential nationalists
and accentuated by the repressive measures introduced
by Tsar Nicholas II, before the revolution of 1905. In
this society Sibelius was deeply influenced by his
association with the family of General Järnefelt, whose
daughter Aino became his wife. Nevertheless
linguistically Swedish remained his mother tongue, in
which he expressed himself more fluently than he could
in Finnish.
The musical abilities of Sibelius were soon realised,
although not developed early enough to suggest music
as a profession until he had entered university in
Helsinki as a law student. His first ambition had been to
be a violinist. It later became apparent that any ability
he had in this direction was outweighed by his gifts as a
composer, developed first by study with Martin
Wegelius, then with the pedantic Becker in Berlin and
with Goldmark and, more effectively, Robert Fuchs in
Vienna.
In Finland once more, Sibelius won almost
immediate success in 1892 with a symphonic poem,
Kullervo, based on an episode from the Finnish epic
Kalevala. There followed compositions of particular
national appeal that further enhanced his reputation in
Helsinki, including the incidental music to the patriotic
student pageant Karelia, En Saga and the
Lemminkäinen Suite. During this period Sibelius
supported himself and his wife by teaching, as well as
by composition and the performance of his works, but it
proved difficult for him to earn enough, given, as he
was, to bouts of extravagance, continuing from his days
as a student. In 1896 he was voted the position of
professor at the University of Helsinki, but the
committee’s decision was overturned in favour of
Robert Kajanus, the experienced founder and conductor
of the first professional orchestra in Helsinki. As
consolation for his disappointment Sibelius was
awarded a government stipend for ten years, and this
was later changed into a pension for life. The sum
involved was never sufficient to meet his gift for
improvidence, inherited, perhaps, from his father, who
at his death in 1868 had left his family in some
difficulty.
Sibelius continued his active career as a composer
until 1926, his fame increasing at home and abroad. The
successful Symphony No. 1 of 1898 was followed by the
still more successful Finlandia. Busoni had tried to
arrange for the publication of his music by Belyayev,
patron of the later nineteenth-century Russian
nationalist composers, on the excuse that the Finns
were, in a sense, Russians, or at least citizens of a
Russian grand-duchy. This came to nothing, but
subsequent publication by Breitkopf and Härtel ensured
a wider public abroad than provincial Finland itself
could ever offer. Symphony No. 2 in 1902 won an
unprecedented success in Helsinki. This was followed
by the Violin Concerto, Symphony No. 3, and after an
illness that put an end for the moment to his indulgence
in alcohol and tobacco Symphony No. 4, with travel to
the major musical centres of Europe and international
honour. Symphony No. 5 was written during the war,
after which Sibelius wrote only four works of any
substance, Symphony No. 6 in 1923 and, in the
following year, Symphony No. 7, incidental music to
Shakespeare’s The Tempest and, in 1926, the
symphonic poem Tapiola. An eighth symphony was
completed in 1929, but destroyed. The rest was silence.
For the last 25 years of his life Sibelius wrote nothing,
remaining isolated from and largely antipathetic to
contemporary trends in music. His reputation in Britain
and America remained high, although there were
inevitable reactions to the excessive enthusiasm of his
supporters. On the continent of Europe he failed to
recapture the earlier position he had enjoyed before the
war of 1914 in Germany, France and Vienna. He died in
1957 at the age of 91.
Sibelius completed the first version of his Violin
Concerto in 1903 and it was first performed in Helsinki
the following year by Victor Nováèek with indifferent
results. The concerto was revised and successfully
performed in Berlin in 1905 by Karl Halir, under the
direction of Richard Strauss. The choice of soloist,
however, offended the violinist Willy Burmester, who
had originally been promised the work. The earlier
version of the concerto was technically ambitious, and
as a violinist Sibelius had needed no help with the layout
of the solo part, although this presented technical
difficulties that were beyond his own command. The
later version made necessary revisions in the solo part
and it is in this definitive form that the work has become
a standard part of the solo repertoire. The work was
dedicated to the young Hungarian virtuoso Ferenc
Vecsey, who had given a later performance of the
concerto in Berlin in the presence of the composer.
The concerto opens with no lengthy orchestral
introduction, the soloist making an almost immediate
appearance, accompanied by a Scandinavian mist of
muted strings. Although the movement is in the
traditional tripartite form, the central development
section is replaced by a cadenza-like passage for the
violinist. The lyrical slow movement brings a deeply
romantic melody, with the soloist proceeding to weave
his own fantasies above the orchestra. There follows a
finale which the composer once described as a danse
macabre, providing an opportunity for virtuoso display
in a work in which the solo part is generally entwined
with the orchestral texture.
The two Serenades for violin and orchestra were
written in 1912 and 1913 respectively. They had their
first performance in Helsinki in 1915 in a fiftieth
birthday programme that included the new
Fifth Symphony and the tone-poem The Oceanides.
The second of the two serenades, the Serenade in
G minor, Op. 69b, opens with a gently lilting theme for
the solo violin, accompanied by the sustained chords of
the muted strings of the orchestra. This forms the basis
of the first part of the work, its initial serenity subtly
threatened by an intrusive and whispered C sharp from
the double basses and timpani. The 6/4 metre of the
opening is changed to duple time with a livelier dotted
theme from the soloist, over a triplet semiquaver
accompaniment, in a section that again finds a place for
the intrusive whispered C sharp, before the brief return
of the opening theme. The dotted rhythm is heard again
and the low C sharp eventually heralds the return of the
first theme, unaccompanied, before the Serenade ends
in final, brief optimism.
Widely remembered by an earlier generation as the
composer of The Rustle of Spring, the Norwegian
composer Christian Sinding was born into a culturally
gifted family in Kongsberg in 1856. He trained first as a
violinist, studying under Schradieck at the Leipzig
Conservatory, where he was also a pupil of Carl
Reinecke and Salomon Jadassohn. During his four years
in Leipzig he turned his attention increasingly to
composition, an art in which he became prolific, writing
very much within the German late Romantic tradition.
He made his real début as a composer in Oslo in 1882,
when his Piano Quartet was performed. Sinding
received state support from Norway from 1880 and in
1924 was given the use of Henrik Wergeland’s house
‘Grotten’ in the castle park in Oslo. Before this he had
generally, since 1874, spent the winter months in
Germany, returning to Åsgårdsstrand in Norway in the
summer.
Sinding left three violin concertos. The first of
these, the Violin Concerto in A major, Op. 45, was
written in 1898. The first movement opens with
cheerful ebullience, its emphatic first theme leading to
a more lyrical secondary theme, of which the soloist
makes much. It is the opening thematic material that
returns, leading to the end of the movement with a final
chord that heralds the more sombre start of the slow
movement, with a finely crafted principal theme,
developed by the soloist in music of general serenity.
This leads without a break to the lively finale, with its
varied episodes offering romantic contrast and thematic
reminiscences, before the energetic conclusion.
Romance in D major, Op. 100, was completed in
1910. Like much of the composer’s other work it
proclaims his Leipzig training in its technical
assurance, its handling of the orchestra and its lyrical
charm. It is, nevertheless, a world away from the
Scandinavia of Sibelius.
Keith Anderson