Ferruccio Busoni was born in Empoli, Italy, in 1866.
His father, Ferdinando, was a virtuoso clarinettist; his mother, Anna Weiss,
was an accomplished pianist. They nurtured the boy’s talents so successfully
that he gave his first public concert before he was eight years old. At ten,
while on a visit to Vienna, he attracted the attention of Eduard Hanslick, the
much-feared critic of Neue Freie Presse, who foretold a brilliant future
for the young pianist. One of Busoni’s most vivid childhood memories dates from
this time. He recalled being taken to Vienna by his parents to hear Liszt play
a concert (March 16, 1877) to raise funds for the erection of a monument in
honour of Beethoven. Liszt was to play the Emperor Concerto. The boy
could not hide his disappointment at Liszt’s restrained style of playing, not
knowing that a short time earlier Liszt had accidentally cut the index finger
of his left hand while shaving. Rather than cancel the concert, Liszt decided
to play the Emperor with the notes distributed among the remaining nine
fingers. The next day Busoni was taken by his mother to play for Liszt, who,
while he was pleased with the boy’s talent, refused to write a testimonial for
him. From such unlikely beginnings, musical history was made. Liszt was central
to Busoni’s development, both as a pianist and as a composer. The shining example
of Liszt’s phenomenal career touched Busoni’s life at a hundred different points.
He edited much of Liszt’s music, and included more of it in his public recitals
than that of any other composer, as an inspection of his printed programmes
shows. He also revived the Weimar masterclasses that Liszt had begun more than
thirty years earlier (this at the personal invitation of Liszt’s former employer,
the Grand Duke Carl Alexander). Busoni himself has told us that when he was
already thirty years old, he began the study of the piano afresh in order to
remedy what he considered to be defects in his playing. He turned to Liszt’s
music. Out of the laws that he found there, Busoni rebuilt his technique. “Gratitude
and admiration”, he wrote, “made Liszt at that time my master and my friend”.
It was not as a pianist that Busoni wished to be remembered, however, but as
a composer. He was always a reluctant virtuoso. This, too, evokes memories of
Liszt. Busoni regarded piano playing as an inferior occupation, thrust upon
him by the sheer necessity of having to make a living. He knew that his remarkable
success as a pianist stood in the way of a wider appreciation of his music,
and he went to his grave lamenting that fact. When Bernard Shaw met Busoni in
London, in 1919, he advised him to compose under a different name, since the
public would never believe that one man could be so supremely gifted in two
branches of music at once. It is a regrettable fact that Busoni’s music, so
striking and original, has not yet found a larger audience, though it has never
lacked for individual advocates. Busoni’s compositions, like Liszt’s, fall into
two great categories: original works and arrangements. His arrangements are
so numerous, and are without exception so wonderfully crafted, that we place
Busoni among the greatest practitioners in this field. His arrangements of Bach,
especially, arouse widespread admiration and are today the most frequently performed
of all Busoni’s works. Yet he had to overcome much prejudice in order to include
them in his recitals. He locked horns in public both with critics and scholars
on this issue, who accused him of desecrating the originals. His reply is worth
noting: “Why are variations considered to be worthy because they change the
original, while arrangements are considered to be unworthy because they too
change the original?” There is no logical answer to that question. If we
wish to understand something of the majesty of Busoni’s piano playing, and the
enthroned golden sound which held his audiences in thrall, we need only turn
to his Bach arrangements. They reveal Busoni’s interest in sonority (a vastly
neglected aspect of piano playing today), and demand a huge range of colour.
The celebrated Chaconne in D minor (c.1897) is a monumental achievement.
It is far more than a simple transfer to the piano keyboard of Bach’s wonderfully
inventive textures for solo violin. Rather, it amounts to a radical re-casting
of Bach’s material, and sounds as if it were born on the keyboard. We are reminded
of Liszt’s penetrating aphorism: “In matters of translation there are some exactitudes
which are the equivalent of infidelities.” The equally famous arrangement of
Bach’s organ Toccata and Fugue in D minor (1900) has captured the imagination
of a number of famous piano transcribers - Tausig and Ignaz Friedman among them.
But it is Busoni’s arrangement that reflects the full grandeur of the organ
(the “king of instruments”) and is heard most frequently in the concert hall.
The remaining arrangement on this disc is that of the Carmen Fantasie (1920),
based on themes from Bizet’s opera. Busoni attached to this ravishing paraphrase
the intriguing subtitle of “Kammerfantasie” (or Chamber Fantasy), thereby revealing
something of its intimate, even anti-virtuosic character. Here Busoni seems
to be brooding at the keyboard. He infuses Bizet’s sometimes trivial melodies
with a mystical quality quite lacking in the originals and ennobles them through
his commentary. He himself gave the first performance of the Fantasie in
London, in 1920. Busoni’s original compositions, too, are represented here.
The four pieces in his Indianisches Tagebuch (1915) flowed from his visits
to America and his growing fascination with the melodies of the North American
Indian, to which his attention had been drawn through the folkloristic studies
of his pupil Natalie Curtis. The melodies are all transcribed and identified
by her in “The Indians’ Book”, a standard text on the subject which Busoni
esteemed. This same volume also provided Busoni with material for his Indian
Fantasy for piano and orchestra, which is thematically linked to the Tagebuch.
Vastly different in style are the Fünf Kurze Stücke (1923), whose
declared artistic purpose was “the study of part-playing”. This is the austere,
problem-solving Busoni at work, the composer of the Fantasia Contrappuntistica
(to which these pieces would form an excellent technical preparation),
and the editor of Bach’s “48”. Typically, he dedicated these pieces to
a pianist whose playing of the classics he greatly admired, Edwin Fischer.
Busoni was profoundly attached to the music of Chopin, and included much
of it in his recitals. He was only eighteen years old when, with all
the audacity of youth, he wrote a set of Variations and Fugue in Free Form
on Chopin’s Prelude in C minor (1884), one of the most over-played pieces
that Chopin ever wrote. Many years later Busoni revisited this piece
and re-cast it as Ten Variations on a Prelude of Chopin (1922). In its
new form, it not only becomes a loving tribute to Chopin, but opens a door to
the future. Busoni’s set of seven Elegies bears the curious subtitle
“New Piano Pieces” (1908), a description which is only partly explained
by their thematic links to some of his earlier music. The Elegie No. 2,
for example, is based on material first composed for the massive Piano
Concerto and takes its title All’Italia! from the last movement
of that work. By calling these pieces “new”, Busoni seems to have had something
more fundamental in mind. Tonality is stretched, bi-tonality emerges,
and the language is generally less compromising, more futuristic. After
he had composed these pieces, in fact, he wrote at the head of the first
of them the phrase “Nach der Wendung” - “after the turning-point”. Busoni
himself said of them: “I finally put down my entire personal vision,
and for the first time, in the Elegies.” These words “personal
vision” are an ideal epitaph for Busoni. For he was a visionary, the like of
which the twentieth-century has not been able to reproduce. When Busoni
died, in 1924, at the lamentably early age of fifty-six, that intrepid
composer-critic Kaikhosru Sorabji wrote a commemorative essay in which he
described Busoni as “an artistic and intellectual Titan”. May these performances
commemorate the memory of the “Titan”, and may Sorabji’s words give us
pause for thought in the year 1999 - the seventy-fifth anniversary of
Busoni’s death.
[ALAN WALKER is the author of the prize-winning, three-volume
biography of Franz Liszt]
VALERIE TRYON’s career as a concert pianist began while
she was still a child. Before she was twelve she had broadcast for the BBC and
was appearing regularly before the public on the concert platform. She wasone
of the youngest students ever to be admitted to the Royal Academy of Music where
she received the highest award in piano playing and a bursary which took her
to Paris for study with Jacques Février. Her place among Britain’s acknowledged
artists was assured when a Cheltenham Festival recital brought her the enthusiastic
acclaim of the country’s foremost critics. Since then she has played in most
of the major concert halls and appeared with many of the leading orchestras
in Britain. Her career has latterly taken her from Britain to North America
where she has appeared in such cities as Toronto, Boston, Washington, Pittsburgh,
Minneapolis, and Los Angeles. She now lives in Canada where she is the Artist-in-Residence
of Hamilton’s McMaster University, but spends a part of each year in her native
Britain. Her repertoire is enormous and ranges from Bach to contemporary composers;
it includes more than sixty concertos and a vast amount of solo and chamber
music. Her passion for solo and chamber music is represented extensively through
concerts and recordings. She presently plays with the Rembrandt Piano Trio (based
in Toronto) which has made a number of recordings for Dorian Records. Her chamber
and solo recordings for CBC Records are critically acclaimed. Harold Schonberg
of the New York Times described her disc (CBC MVCD 1092), CHOPIN; SCHERZOS
AND BALLADES, as “the most significant Chopin recording of the past
decade.” Valerie Tryon has been awarded several distinctions for her service
to music. She was an early recipient of the Harriet Cohen Medal. More recently,
the Liszt Memorial Plaque was bestowed on her by the Hungarian Minister of Culture
in recognition of her lifelong promotion of Franz Liszt’s music.