ClassicsOnline Home » BUSONI, F.: Piano Music, Vol. 3 (Harden) - 3 morceaux / Indianisches Tagebuch, Book 1
The essence of Busoni’s music lies in a synthesis of his Italian and German ancestry: emotion and intellect, imagination and discipline, often allied with a re-creative approach to the musical past. His arrangement of Bach’s Toccata, Adagio and Fugue in D minor, BWV565 represents the virtuoso transcription, derived from Brahms and Liszt, at its most commanding. Tanzwalzer, dedicated ‘to the memory of Johann Strauss’ is a homage to the golden age of the Viennese waltz. Drawing on Amerindian rhythms and melodies, the Indian Diary depicts life among the North American Indians whose wretched plight Busoni had witnessed on a visit to America in 1910.
By David Denton
Ferruccio Busoni changed his colours more frequently than a
chameleon, wrestling with his personal conflict between that of remaining true
to the influences of the Baroque - and in particular to the music of Bach -
while wishing to relate to progressive composers of his own time. Without prior
knowledge you never quite know what to expect when 'discovering' his music.
Born in Italy in 1866 to intensely musical parents, he made his piano debut
at the age of eight, and it was as a concert performer and composer of piano
music that he made his career until 1902. There was then a sudden shift to conducting
and an affinity to all that was new. That he was under the spell of Bach as
a teenager is evident in the typical fugue that ends the Three Morceaux , then
we leap into the world of Liszt for the first two of his Ballet Scenes, often
light in texture and always happy of character. Back to Bach for the first of
Two Dance Pieces, which act as a foil to the salon style of the charming Fourth
Ballet Scene. In the last period of his life comes the Indian Diary,
a work based on a collection of North American Indian ideas, with Debussy hovering
in the background. It seems an age since Wolf Harden gave us the second volume
of this on-going series. His easy brilliance makes the prodigious difficulties
disappear, while the densely scored arrangement of Bach's Toccata, Adagio and
Fugue is given inner clarity by nimble fingers. That fact is aided by one of
the best recordings of a piano I have ever heard from Naxos or indeed from any
Ferruccio Busoni (1866-1924)
Piano Music • 3
Dante Michelangeli Benvenuto Ferruccio Busoni was born at Empoli (near Florence) in 1866, the only child of a clarinettist father and pianist mother. He made his piano début in Trieste in 1874, going to Vienna the next year. On the advice of Brahms he moved to Leipzig in 1885, studying with Carl Reinecke, before teaching in Helsinki and Moscow. Performance occupied much of his time until the turn of the century, when composing began to assume a new importance, though never dominance, in his career. Apart from living in Zurich during the First World War, he made his home in Berlin from 1894 until his death in 1924.
The essence of Busoni's music lies in a synthesis of his Italian and German ancestry: emotion and intellect, imagination and discipline. Despite acclaim from both composer and performer colleagues, his work for long remained the preserve of an informed few. Neither inherently conservative nor demonstratively radical, his harmonic and tonal innovations were bound up with a re-creative approach to the musical past that has only gained wider currency over recent decades.
Bach was a pervasive presence from the outset, whether in the contrapuntal aspect of Busoni's music, or his repertoire as performer, culminating in the Bach-Busoni Edition. While Busoni's later Bach-related work is more interpretation than arrangement, his personality is inherent in the earliest transcriptions. One such is the Toccata, Adagio and Fugue in C major, BWV 564. Among several reworkings of organ pieces made around 1900, and allotted to Volume Three of 'Bach-Busoni', it represents the virtuoso transcription, derived from Brahms and Liszt, at its most commanding.
A peremptory call to attention, and the Toccata sets off in determined fashion, the theme given in unison octaves before opening out into expansive part-writing across the keyboard. At length the theme is restated and the piece brought to a powerful conclusion. By contrast, the Adagio receives a limpid and affecting treatment, moving forward in measured paragraphs towards a brief climax before regaining its initial poise. An imposing cadenza-like passage prepares for the Fugue: among Bach's most witty and animated, this expounds its main and subsidiary ideas with due purposefulness, before moving into a stretto that draws constituent parts into a decisive and affirmative conclusion.
The years 1883-84 saw the composing of the young Busoni's most impressive and virtuosic piano works, not least the Sonata in F minor and the Variations and Fugue after Chopin [Naxos 8.555699]. Of the smaller pieces from this time, the Trois Morceaux, published in Vienna as the composer's Op. 4, 5 and 6respectively, are among the most engaging. The Scherzo is a finely-worked miniature whose incisive outer sections enclose a more lilting, though not necessarily more relaxed, trio which returns as the basis for an understated coda. Bachian in its melodic inspiration, the Prelude exudes a robust charm, while the Fugue is a forceful example of the form, highly-wrought both in its texture and part-writing. The influence of Liszt pervades the (First) Ballet Scene, whose lively and impulsive themes are perhaps more redolent of the country-dance than the ball-room, with a distinct rigour that pointedly offsets any more suave or gallant tendency.
'Ballet-scene' is a term that appears frequently in Busoni's music at this time, there being four examples (and also an unfinished fifth) over the course of a decade. Written in 1884 and published as Op. 20, the Second Ballet Scene is more extended than its predecessor. Related in key and also texture, its two main themes (the second in tarantella rhythm) evince a more effervescent approach to the title; building a rhythmic momentum that carries through into the sparkling coda.
The 'Third Ballet Scene' was actually entitled Little Ballet Scene and, as the second of Two Pieces (the first entitled Contrapuntal Dance Piece) composed in 1889, was published as Busoni's Op. 30. In 1914 he revised and republished these pieces as Waffentanz and Friedenstanz respectively. Waffentanz is a finely-argued study in contrapuntal dexterity, and exhibits a modulatory freedom in its middle section. Friedenstanz is among Busoni's most resourceful pieces: one that exudes wit and ingenuity in the transformation of its melodic ideas.
The Fourth Ballet Suite – or, to give its full title, Fourth Ballet Scene in the Form of a Concert Waltz – appeared in 1894 and is among Busoni's most impressive display pieces. A brief introduction presents the salient melodic ideas in outline, before the main theme, suave and sophisticated in equal measure, unfolds over two, progressively more elaborate stages. An intricately-wrought central section makes passing reference back to the opening bars, and then the main theme intently resumes its course; this time leading up to a hectic galop which brings the whole piece to a tumultuous and exhilarating conclusion. Busoni's virtuosity, as pianist or composer, is nowhere better demonstrated.
Tanzwalzer presents a radically different concept of music designed as entertainment. Composed as an orchestral piece in 1920, and heard here in the idiomatic transcription from 1921 by Busoni's pupil Michael von Zadora, this is one of many pieces that emerged as 'satellites' around the music-drama Doktor Faust on which Busoni worked (and left unfinished) during the last eight years of his life. Not that its lofty aspirations are evident from Tanzwalzer, whose dedication 'to the memory of Johann Strauss' indicates its intention: a homage to the golden-age of the Viennese waltz as pertinent as, if less sardonic than, Ravel's La valse. Dispensing with the dryly humorous introduction, the transcription commences with the elegant first waltz, taking in the energetic second waltz before heading into the respective elegance and whimsy of the third and fourth waltzes. The music passes through an ambivalent review of its earlier ideas, at length recalling the first waltz, after which, a spirited coda brings about the decisive ending.
The years 1913-15 saw an intense preoccupation with Amerindian culture and music. Brought about by the presentation to Busoni by Natalie Curtis (a former pupil) of her collection Indians' Book in 1911, it offered a way forward from the introspection that pervaded his music of the previous three years. After the Indian Fantasy for piano and orchestra, Busoni composed his Indian Diary in 1915. The opening Allegretto (closely related to the initial unaccompanied section of the Fantasy) has an improvisatory quality. This is followed by a hectic Vivace, drawing on a Cheyenne melody in music as fluid in motion as it is quixotic in manner. The Andante is a 'romance' of tender simplicity, its main melody derived from the song 'The Blue Bird' and with a central section, derived from the 'Laguna Corn-Grinding Song' whose repose confirms Busoni's identity with the source of his inspiration. A fervent Maestoso concludes the set with questing and determined resolve, also introducing an element of counterpoint that reconciles the American and the European in Busoni's creativity with a subtle conclusiveness wholly typical of the composer's maturity.