REGISTER NOW AND GET
• 5 FREE tracks! • 101 tracks for $9.99
ClassicsOnline Home » MENDELSSOHN: Lieder ohne Worte (Songs Without Words) (arr. F. Hermann for violin and piano)
The series of Songs without Words that Mendelssohn wrote for piano and published from 1830 onwards serve as a very personal musical diary, purely and simply expressing its own musical meaning without verbal connotation. In arranging some of them for violin and piano the Leipzig violinist Friedrich Hermann was able to create a useful addition to the repertoire of his instrument without making any significant changes to the texture and form of the original compositions.
By Stephen Chin
Late in life, Mendelssohn wrote a Song Without Words for cello and piano and unfortunately it was the only work of this type he wrote for strings. A generation later, Friederich Hermann, one of Mendelssohn’s students, arranged many of the Songs Without Words originally for piano for violin and piano. They work remarkably well, enhancing all the manifest lyricism and drama. Strauss’s playing is warm, refined urbane and sensitive to the many changes of moods between the songs. It would be a welcome addition to the violin repertoire if these out-of-print works were readily available. A delightful compilation.
By Andrew Fraser
Axel Strauss is an excellent violinist who plays these with wit and verve and, when required, a plaintive restraint. Pianist Cord Garben accepts his moderate role with good grace. The recording, made in Germany in 1999, is of the highest standard while the sleeve naote are typically brief for the label, but well-written. This set may well be a curiosity, but it is exactly the repertoire with which a company like Naxos can excel. Moreover when the performance is as well played as this and comes at a budget price, it merits serious consideration.
By David Denton
p >Friedrich Hermann was for a short time a composition student
of Mendelssohn, though his lasting fame would be as a violin teacher and the
editor of many works for use by students. Among his many arrangements was this
group of twenty-two Songs without words, though the word 'arrangement'
is misleading, Hermann leaving the music exactly as it was, and simply giving
the melody to the violin with the remainder of the original piano piece as the
accompaniment. I must confess the result sounds rather like Fritz Kreisler's
pastiche pieces, the music amiable enough and well within the scope of reasonably
proficient amateurs. There is really nothing to tax the German-born Axel Strauss,
his tone warm, intonation never questionable, and the two musicians have balanced
themselves to keep the melody nicely seated on top. The engineers have played
their part by retaining that status. A disc in Naxos's 'Limited Edition' category
that may best be obtained from your Internet provider.
Felix Mendelssohn (1809–1847)
Songs without Words (selection), arranged for violin and piano
Born in Hamburg in 1809, eldest son of the banker Abraham Mendelssohn and grandson of the great Jewish thinker Moses Mendelssohn, Felix Mendelssohn, who took the additional name Bartholdy on his baptism as a Christian, Heine's ticket of admission to European culture, was brought up in Berlin, where his family settled in 1812. Here he enjoyed the wide cultural opportunities that his family offered, through their own interests and connections. His early gifts, manifested in a number of directions, included marked musical precocity, both as a player and as a performer, at a remarkably early age.
Mendelssohn's early manhood brought the opportunity to travel, as far south as Naples and as far north as The Hebrides, with Italy and Scotland both providing the inspiration for later symphonies. His career involved him in the Lower Rhine Festival in Düsseldorf and a period as city director of music, followed, in 1835, by appointment as conductor of the Gewandhaus Orchestra in Leipzig. Here he was able to continue the work he had started in Berlin six years earlier, when he had conducted in Berlin a revival of Bach's St Matthew Passion. Leipzig was to provide a degree of satisfaction that he could not find in Berlin, where he returned at the invitation of King Friedrich Wilhelm IV in 1841. In Leipzig once more, in 1843, he established a new Conservatory, spending his final years there, until his death at the age of 38 on 4th November 1847, six months after the death of his gifted and beloved sister Fanny.
To contemporaries of Mendelssohn the notion of songs without words seemed paradoxical. If there were no words, there could be no song. Yet what Mendelssohn achieved was exactly what his title suggested, music in its purest and simplest form, expressing its own musical meaning, imbued with feeling, but without verbal connotation. He expressed strong views about the inevitably ambiguous nature of words, a judgement commonly applied by his contemporaries to music. At the same time short piano pieces of this kind would always find a ready amateur market and would be welcomed by publishers, although this may have been irrelevant to the composer's purpose. The series of Songs without Words that Mendelssohn wrote and published from 1830 onwards serve as a very personal musical diary in which the composer expressed very precisely musical ideas that had, he alleged, no verbal equivalent. It was left to later publishers to suggest titles for the pieces, a procedure that Mendelssohn himself deplored. Nevertheless the publisher's titles are included here, as well as the very small number of verbal indications authorised by the composer.
The Opus 19 collection of Songs without Words was the first to be published, appearing in August 1832, originally under the title Melodies for the Pianoforte. Marked Andante con moto the first of the set [Track 22] offers a simple and attractive melody, with a divided chordal accompaniment. The fourth , given the title Confidence by the publisher, has a more chordal figuration in its accompaniment, while the fifth  gives some justification for the publisher's suggested title Restlessness.
The second set of half a dozen pieces appeared in Bonn in 1835 as Opus 30. The first of the set  is meditative in mood, while the third  has been given the English title Consolation. The turbulent fourth piece  has the assumed title The Wanderer and the sixth  has the composer's sanctioned title of Venetian Boat-Song.
A third set of pieces was published two years later, in 1837, as Opus 38. The group opens with The Evening Star , a lilting 12/8. From the same set comes the second piece, perhaps familiar as Lost Happiness , the fourth , with its arpeggio introduction, Hope, and the sixth , with its descriptive and sanctioned title Duet, as one voice answers another.
A further group, the fourth, was published in 1841 as Opus 53. From this come the third , marked Presto agitato, the fourth  in more meditative mood, and the fifth , Folk-Song, which seems to grow in power as new voices join the song.
1844 brought the fifth collection, Opus 62, from which four pieces have been chosen. The first , with the slightly inappropriate editorial title of May Breezes, is in a very different mood from the third , which is a funeral march. The fourth , written in 1843, has the editorial title Morning Song and the sixth  is very familiar as Spring Song.
The sixth group was the last to be published in Mendelssohn's life-time. It was issued in 1845 as Opus 67 and was to be followed by two further, posthumous collections. The first , Meditation, was written in 1844, while the delicate second piece  dates from 1839. The hymn-like third of the set  has been given the title Song of the Pilgrim, and the fifth  The Shepherd's Complaint.
Friedrich Hermann (1828–1907)
In 1843 Friedrich Hermann entered the Leipzig Conservatory, which had just been founded by Felix Mendelssohn, and became a violin student of Ferdinand David. He also studied composition with Moritz Hauptmann and Mendelssohn himself. He later joined the Leipzig Gewandhaus Orchestra and was appointed Professor of Violin at the Leipzig Conservatory in 1848. Violin students will remember Friedrich Hermann as the editor of many violin works published by the Peters Edition. He also wrote a violin manual and was a prolific arranger and composer. According to a contemporary "in 1852 a symphony of his composition was executed at the Gewandhaus concerts with great success". Hermann's violin and piano arrangement of the Songs Without Words works exceptionally well and provides a wonderful addition to the violin repertoire. The word "arrangement" is almost an overstatement because Hermann did not add anything to the music. He merely divided melody and accompaniment and managed to leave the nature of the originals completely untouched.
Last Albums Viewed
MENDELSSOHN: Lieder ohne Worte (Songs Without Word...