REGISTER NOW AND GET
• 5 FREE tracks! • 101 tracks for $9.99
ClassicsOnline Home » BEETHOVEN, L. van: Violin Sonatas (Complete), Vol. 2 (Fuchs, Balsam) - Nos. 5-7 (1952)
Described by Nathan Milstein as ‘the greatest American-trained violinist’, Joseph Fuchs had an immensely long career, continuing to give recitals at Carnegie Hall until he was 93. He was a soloist with every major American orchestra and made many important recordings, including the concertos by Hindemith and Vaughan Williams, as well as Mozart’s G major and Sinfonia concertante. For many years Fuchs had a duo with the pianist Artur Balsam with whom he made several recordings, including the Beethoven Violin Sonatas of which this disc forms the second of three volumes. Apart from being the first complete cycle on the new vinyl medium, this one set a high standard in quality of both recording and performance. In his review of the original LP release in the December 21, 1952 New York Times Harold C Schonberg wrote: “Fuchs and Balsam make a magnificent team… Both instrumentalists scorn effects of a superficial nature and probe directly to the music’s bone.These are strong, powerful, thoughtful performances that have the added virtue of being technically impeccable”.
By Rob Cowan
Collaborations of sweetness and musical poetry
Among the less predicted delights of Naxos’s “historical” series is a set of Beethoven’s violin sonatas with Joseph Fuchs (who died in March 1997, just a few weeks short of his 98th birthday) and Artur Balsam at the piano, which is now two-thirds available. The nearest violinist to Fuchs in terms of style is Szymon Goldberg. Both players favoured a profoundly classical approach and both produced a warm, often sweet sound which never lapsed into sentimentality or called excessively on such expressive devices as vibrato or slides, which are always tastefully applied. Balsam was an evident soul-mate for Fuchs, musically speaking, and the first two volumes of Naxos’s survey cover Sonatas Nos 1–4 and 5–7, respectively.
By Jonathan Woolf
These are the first two volumes in what will be a three CD conspectus—available singly—of the first complete LP cycle of the Beethoven Violin Sonatas [Vol 1 8.111251, Vol 2 8.111252]. American Decca chose that stalwart musician, Warsaw-born Artur Balsam as the pianist. He’d already accompanied Milstein and was to be more famous as Menuhin’s partner, though he partnered the elite of the string playing profession over the years; Goldberg, Francescatti and Szigeti among many. The violinist, Joseph Fuchs, was born in 1899 and was seven years Balsam’s senior. For much of his career he was known as an important concertmaster, initially at Cleveland. He was first violinist in the Primrose Quartet after Shumsky’s departure and formed a well-known duo with his sister, violist Lillian. They were renowned for their performance of the Sinfonia Concertante and for inspiring Martinů’s Three Madrigals.
The Fuchs-Balsam duo combined what sleeve note writer Tully Potter characterises as ‘virtuoso-conscious New World taste, along with a touch of Old World graciousness.’ The extent to which one goes along with that statement is the extent to which one will enjoy the performances. The seven sonatas enshrined in these two discs share consonant qualities; instrumental finesse, a good sense of tempo relations, fine ensemble. The E flat major [No.3] has a gracefully phrased opening movement and a buoyant finale. Its slow movement is quite subtly coloured by Fuchs, with some clean and modern sounding expressive finger position changes. The corollary is that it can sound rather sleek and for all the adroit musicality the rather fast vibrato tends to limit optimum colour.
The Spring Sonata shares these qualities. When I first played it I thought it sounded uncommonly fast but it’s the nature of the accenting and the quickness of the rhythmic corners being turned that leads one to think so. It’s actually a good, well-chosen tempo. Again though, in the end, one’s pleasure in the athleticism and clear eyed pragmatism of the performances is slightly vitiated by something a little too unyielding in Fuchs’s tone. There’s a lack of real tonal breadth and for all the collegiate association, that’s a constant of the performance. The A major [No.6] is polished but emotively a little reserved. Fuchs’s sound, whilst certainly exciting and vibrant can tend toward the one dimensional in terms strictly of colour. The result is that the slow movements in particular can sound a little starved of variety and also of characterisation. The C minor [No.7] is properly assertive and theatrical, dynamic and outward looking, but once more the basic sound is a little tense, and fortes can sound razory to the point of shrillness.
I can’t comment meaningfully on the quality of the engineering as I’ve never heard the Deccas from which these transfers derive. It sounds broadly unproblematic. These discs constitute two-thirds of a pioneering LP set, which has long been absent. Its restoration is welcome but recommendation will depend on the specialisation of one’s tastes.
By David Denton
Never seeking popular acclaim, Joseph Fuchs was regarded as one of the most perceptive violinists of his time, this first LP recording of the complete Beethoven Violin Sonatas being his major achievement on disc.
Born in New York in 1899, he passed through the days of an infant prodigy to become the Concertmaster of the Cleveland Orchestra. A fall led to the loss of use in his left-hand fingers, and only through an experimental operation, followed a long period of rehabilitation, was he again able to play. Wishing to avoid the constant demands of orchestral life, he concentrated on solo work and teaching, that combination extending his career through to the age of 93. He made few recordings, but in 1952 was asked by American Decca to place the Beethoven Violin Sonatas on disc. Initially released for the US market, they eventually arrived in Europe on the Brunswick label, and were generally regarded as the new performing benchmark. Maybe his fast vibrato and honeyed tone is a throwback to playing of a previous generation, but the affection he brings to the ‘Spring’ Sonata is typical of his endearing musicianship. His elegant legato playing created long flowing lines to the slow movement, while the final Rondo is full of joy. Always technically immaculate, those same characteristics are carried over into the Sixth and Seventh Sonatas that complete the disc. His pianist, Artur Balsam, was a Beethoven exponent of distinction, and was more than an equal partner, bringing an inner strength around which Fuchs could weave a web of musical decoration. You do have to adjust your ears to the rather constricted sound, but the transfers from immaculate original pressings are of outstanding quality.
Great Violinists • Joseph Fuchs (1899-1997)
BEETHOVEN: Complete Violin Sonatas • 2
My father, Joseph Fuchs, started playing the violin at the age of four, quite literally by accident. When he was three, while playing with a friend, he fell off the family’s kitchen table and broke his left arm. When the cast came off, the arm was weak, and his doctor recommended that the boy take violin lessons to strengthen it. By the time he was six he was recognized as a prodigy, and was given a full scholarship to the Institute of Musical Art, today the Juilliard School, from which he graduated with highest honors at nineteen.
In his mid-thirties, towards the end of his twelve-year tenure as Concertmaster of the Cleveland Orchestra, my father began to suffer a strange numbness in his left hand. In the midst of a performance he would sometimes be forced to play with only two fingers because the others would not respond. Soon he entirely lost the use of his fifth finger. Cleveland doctors were mystified, but finally, a New York neurologist concluded that a bone chip from the childhood fall was impinging on the ulnar nerve. The doctor told my father that an experimental “nerve transplant” operation to move the nerve from the back of the arm to the front was the only chance to prevent an imminent paralysis of the left hand.
I only understood the full story of the accident and its aftermath as a young adult, when I questioned my father about the long, vivid scar along his elbow, as well as the almost translucent web of skin between his thumb and index finger where muscle had atrophied, replaced by highly developed muscle elsewhere.
The doctors had warned him that the operation might not succeed, he told me, but not that he would need to retrain himself to play the violin if it did succeed. It took a year of persistent, arduous practicing to restore full strength and dexterity to his left arm. After his recovery he made a decision to seek a wider musical life. He returned to New York to launch the solo performance, recording, and teaching careers for which he is best remembered today.
Just as the original accident ignited my father’s career, its sequel, with its severe demands for retraining and the lifelong habits it re-enforced of continuous practice, may have played a rôle in his astonishingly long musical life. At 89 he offered a New York recital program composed entirely of difficult contemporary works. At his ninetieth birthday he was interviewed on television and radio as a rare example of the working nonagenarian. At 93, an age at which, as his great-nephew, a physician, joked, it would be a feat for most people to even get to Carnegie Hall, he gave his last Carnegie Hall recital. At 97, though in failing health, he continued to teach from home. One day, I listened in as he coached a Juilliard student and his accompanist in their performance of a Beethoven sonata. At one point in the first movement he clapped his hands to stop them. My father, whose memory of the violin literature was legendary, called out to the pianist, “There’s a B-flat missing in the left hand!”
Ludwig van Beethoven followed Mozart in being a great concert pianist and thinking of his violin sonatas as works for piano with violin accompaniment. How strange, then, that especially in America in the first half of the last century, these sonatas were often played by star violinists with second-rank pianists who were hired as accompanists. The first thing that needs to be emphasized about the performances on this disc is that, while the violinist is undoubtedly a magnificent artist, the pianist is equally good. The unfortunate Artur Balsam was forced, through economic necessity, to work as a mere accompanist in the early part of his career. Tossed around Europe by the turbulent politics of the 1930s, he finally reached the friendly shores of America in the 1940s; but initially he still had to take work as an accompanist – and although by the time of these recordings he had asserted himself as a soloist, he never quite threw off his ‘second class’ rating with American impresarios. Today, by the simple (and enjoyable) process of listening to him, we can correct that injustice. Lend an ear, for instance, to his work in the C minor Sonata, where the pianist has to create the requisite atmosphere in all four movements. One of the pleasures of listening to these Beethoven interpretations is to find the players treating each other like equals and passing phrases back and forth with aplomb, spontaneity and total security of technique.
The violinist Joseph Philip Fuchs, born in New York City on 26 April 1899, was part of a profoundly musical family: father Philip was an amateur violinist, sister Lillian (1902–95) was a superb violist and brother Harry (1908–86) an excellent cellist. Joseph had his first lessons at four from his father – therapy suggested by a doctor after the boy had broken his left arm – and then studied at the Institute of Musical Art (now the Juilliard School) with Louis Svecenski (1862–1926), who had been violist of the Kneisel Quartet. In due course Fuchs graduated to the class of Franz Kneisel (1865–1926), who represented the best of the Viennese school. Born in Bucharest of German parentage, Kneisel was taught at the Vienna Conservatory by Jakob Grün and Joseph Hellmesberger and moved to America in 1885 to lead the Boston Symphony, also founding his celebrated Quartet. As chamber musician, soloist, conductor and teacher, he had an incalculable influence on music in America.
The career of Joseph Fuchs was to bear an uncanny resemblance to that of his teacher, although to the occupations of concertmaster, chamber musician and teacher he added a soloist’s reputation. Graduating in 1918, in 1919 he made his first trip to Europe, meeting Busoni and playing the Brahms Concerto in Frankfurt, Munich and Berlin. On 12 November 1920 he made a successful home début at the Aeolian Hall in New York, critics writing of ‘artistic finish of style’, ‘musical intelligence’, ‘brilliancy and dash’ and ‘one of the most gifted young violinists who has appeared recently before this public’. In 1926 he became leader of the Cleveland Orchestra and the Cleveland Quartet, displaying his prowess by performing the Brahms Concerto under the orchestra’s chief conductor Nikolai Sokoloff. ‘He produces one of the most beautiful tones to emanate from a violin on a local stage for a long time’, a critic wrote. Three recorded souvenirs of this period are his solos on Artur Rodzinski’s recordings of Strauss’s Ein Heldenleben and Till Eulenspiegel and Rimsky-Korsakov’s Scheherazade – after hearing the latter, the conductor telegraphed to his agent: ‘FUCHS SOLOS JUST A DREAM’. In the late 1930s the violinist’s career was almost ended by repercussions from his childhood injury, but he made a full recovery. Resigning in 1940 to give himself more time for solo work, Fuchs became an essential part of the New York scene. In 1941 he took over leadership of the Primrose Quartet from Oscar Shumsky – this ensemble sadly disbanded in 1943. In 1945 he gave the première of Nikolai Lopatnikoff’s concerto; and he and Lillian gave their first performance of Mozart’s Sinfonia concertante, which became one of their signature pieces, along with the composer’s two Duos. Early in 1947 Fuchs and William Kroll founded the Musicians’ Guild, which presented first-rate programmes of chamber music for eleven seasons. The inaugural concert featured Bohuslav Martinů’s String Sextet, with the composer present – and hearing Joseph and Lillian Fuchs play Mozart’s B flat Duo in the same programme, Martinů was inspired to write his beautiful Three Madrigals for them: they gave the première of the pieces later that year. Among other works introduced by Joseph Fuchs were the concertos by Ben Weber, Mario Peragallo and Walter Piston.
Fuchs, who played on the 1722 ‘Cádiz’ Stradivarius, had an immensely long career, continuing to give Carnegie Hall recitals until he was 93. He toured a good deal, appearing at the 1953 and 1954 Casals Festivals in Prades as well as in other European centres, South America, the Soviet Union, Israel and Japan. By the end of his life he had been a soloist with every American orchestra worth mentioning. Among his recordings were the concertos by Hindemith and Vaughan Williams, as well as Mozart’s G major Concerto and three versions of the Sinfonia concertante with Lillian, one of them live, with Pablo Casals conducting. The Mozart Duos were recorded twice, the Martinů Madrigals once. In 1946 he became a professor at the Juilliard School, a post he kept until his death, and he was soon regarded as an important teacher. In 1953 he was appointed professor of music at Yale University, a position he held until 1959. In the same year Fuchs was a co-founder, with the violist Marianne Kneisel and Artur Balsam, of the summer chamber music school Kneisel Hall in Blue Hill, Maine, established in honour of Franz Kneisel on the site of Kneisel’s own summer school decades earlier. In 1981 Fuchs founded the summer chamber music institute at Alfred University in Alfred, New York, where he was Artistic Director until 1994. He died on 14 March 1997.
For many years Fuchs had a duo with Artur Balsam – in 1969 they introduced the revised version of Vaughan Williams’s Sonata to America and their recordings included the sonatas by Franck, Fauré (No.1), Strauss and Piston. Balsam was from the Polish school that gave us Chopin, Hofmann, Neuhaus, Artur Rubinstein, Friedman, Malcuzynski, Czerny-Stefanska and Zimerman. Born in Warsaw on 8th February 1906, he studied with Lewandowski at the Lódz Conservatory, making his début in that city with Bach’s D minor Concerto in 1918, and with Curt Börner at the Berlin Hochschule, also taking lessons from Leonid Kreutzer and Artur Schnabel. He won the 1930 Berlin International Piano Competition and the following year took the Mendelssohn Prize for his duo with Roman Totenberg. In 1933 he married Ruth Miller, a fellow Lewandowski pupil. In 1938 he began accompanying Nathan Milstein and in 1940 he and Ruth followed the violinist to America, becoming United States citizens in 1948. Among other string players he partnered were Busch, Francescatti, Garbousova, Goldberg, Menuhin, Morini, Nelsova, Shumsky and Szigeti. Balsam was Toscanini’s orchestral pianist in the mid-1940s and appeared regularly with the Budapest Quartet in the 1950s. He recorded a number of concertos, all the piano sonatas by Haydn and Mozart, the violin sonatas by Mozart and Brahms (as well as this Beethoven set), and the Beethoven cello sonatas. He was a member of the Albeneri Trio from 1960 and taught at the Eastman School of Music of the University of Rochester, and the Manhattan School in his home town of New York. He participated in the chamber music summer school at Kneisel Hall for four decades. Having made his last appearance at Carnegie Weill Recital Hall on 14 February 1993, he died in New York City on 1 September 1994.
The lovely recordings on this disc were made in 1952 in New York, as part of a complete cycle, and issued on the Decca Gold Label Series. Over the course of several months in 1954 all ten sonatas were released in Britain on the Brunswick label, and they stayed in the catalogue for a decade. Apart from being the first integral cycle on the new vinyl medium, this one set a high standard in quality of both recording and performance. The present volume includes perhaps the most agreeable sonata, the ‘Spring’, as well as the most dramatic, the Sonata in C minor, and the delightful ‘Little A major’. All the manifold problems of these evergreen pieces are solved by Fuchs and Balsam. At more than half a century’s distance, the style of the playing seems not at all old-fashioned: it has the polish required by the virtuoso-conscious New World taste, along with a touch of Old World graciousness. The entire series is a fine memorial to two exceptional artists.
Last Albums Viewed
BEETHOVEN, L. van: Violin Sonatas (Complete), Vol....